PDA

View Full Version : Prof only intended to 'tap' bicyclist she ran over


Robert J. Matter
June 9th 05, 01:45 PM
http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/dn/latestnews/stories/060905dnmetsmuprof.12bebec93.html

Officer: SMU prof admitted 'tap'

Dallas: He says she denied trying to run down bicyclist

10:16 PM CDT on Wednesday, June 8, 2005

By DAKARAI I. AARONS / The Dallas Morning News

A police officer testified Wednesday that Southern Methodist University
law professor Jane Dolkart told him she only intended to tap a bicyclist
with her car the day she allegedly ran him down.

Officer Craig Bennight's testimony came on the first day of Ms.
Dolkart's trial. She is charged with aggravated assault with a deadly
weapon.

Ms. Dolkart is accused of using her car to hit lawyer Tommy Thomas last
May while he was biking with a friend at White Rock Lake on West Lawther
Drive south of Mockingbird Lane. Mr. Thomas suffered minor injuries as
he was dragged under the car.

Officer Bennight testified that Ms. Dolkart said Mr. Thomas had
intentionally blocked her efforts to get around him.

He also testified that when he told Ms. Dolkart that Mr. Thomas was
claiming she had intentionally hit him, "that kind of unleashed a
torrent of anger" from her.

Officer Bennight said Ms. Dolkart told him that claim was absurd and
that, "I only meant to tap him."

She was arrested shortly thereafter.

During cross-examination, defense attorney Mike Gibson questioned the
thoroughness of the police investigation, noting that officers never
went back to the scene with Ms. Dolkart.

They also did not hold her car as evidence, even though Officer Bennight
said it was used as a deadly weapon.During opening arguments, Mr. Gibson
said evidence would show that Ms. Dolkart accidentally hit Mr. Thomas
and that the proper place for this matter is a civil court.

"Just because a car and bicycle collided on a road, it doesn't make it a
crime," Mr. Gibson said.

Officer Bennight later testified that he and his partner spent time
discussing the incident with both parties to determine whether the
collision had been an accident or intentional.

"We both concurred there was no evidence it was an accident," he said.
"Ms. Dolkart never said it was an accident."

Mr. Thomas is expected to testify Thursday.

If convicted, Ms. Dolkart could face two to 20 years in prison and a
fine of up to $10,000.

E-mail

AustinMN
June 9th 05, 02:17 PM
The cager in this proves the adage "Those who can't do, teach." No
lawyer worth paying a cent for would ever admit anything to a cop (plea
bargans excepted), least of all intentionally hitting someone with a
car!

Austin

Rich
June 9th 05, 04:10 PM
AustinMN wrote:
> No
> lawyer worth paying a cent for would ever admit anything to a cop (plea
> bargans excepted), least of all intentionally hitting someone with a
> car!

Maybe an honest lawyer?

Just zis Guy, you know?
June 9th 05, 04:47 PM
On Thu, 09 Jun 2005 09:10:28 -0600, Rich >
wrote:

>Maybe an honest lawyer?

http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=oxymoron


Guy
--
http://www.chapmancentral.co.uk

"Let’s have a moment of silence for all those Americans who are stuck
in traffic on their way to the gym to ride the stationary bicycle."
- Earl Blumenauer

catzz66
June 9th 05, 05:46 PM
Robert J. Matter wrote:
> ..
>
> A police officer testified Wednesday that Southern Methodist University
> law professor Jane Dolkart told him she only intended to tap a bicyclist
> with her car the day she allegedly ran him down.
>
> Officer Craig Bennight's testimony came on the first day of Ms.
> Dolkart's trial. She is charged with aggravated assault with a deadly
> weapon.
>
> Ms. Dolkart is accused of using her car to hit lawyer Tommy Thomas last
> May while he was biking with a friend at White Rock Lake on West Lawther
> Drive south of Mockingbird Lane. Mr. Thomas suffered minor injuries as
> he was dragged under the car.
>
>

I've not heard of this case before. I have ridden there many times.
There's probably not a busier place in the area for bikers and runners.
What a bizarre story!

catzz66
June 9th 05, 05:53 PM
Here's an earlier story I just found...

http://www.lawschool.com/texasprofindicted.htm

It tells more about this incident. The driver had previously hit some
pedestrians (law students) near SMU law school where she teaches.

"In December [2003], Ms. Dolkart struck two SMU second-year law students
as they crossed Hillcrest Avenue near the university campus. Ms Dolkart
told police that she had not seen the pedestrians because the sun was in
her eyes. A police report ruled that the sun would not have blocked her
view of the pedestrians and that she had failed to check the crosswalk."

treynolds@my-deja.com
June 9th 05, 05:54 PM
AustinMN wrote:
> The cager in this proves the adage "Those who can't do, teach." No
> lawyer worth paying a cent for would ever admit anything to a cop (plea
> bargans excepted), least of all intentionally hitting someone with a
> car!
>
The cyclist is the lawyer, not the motorist.

Jim Smith
June 9th 05, 06:01 PM
" > writes:

> AustinMN wrote:
>> The cager in this proves the adage "Those who can't do, teach." No
>> lawyer worth paying a cent for would ever admit anything to a cop (plea
>> bargans excepted), least of all intentionally hitting someone with a
>> car!
>>
> The cyclist is the lawyer, not the motorist.

The motorist is a law professor herself. The whole place must be
crawling with 'em...

Maggie
June 9th 05, 06:11 PM
Rich wrote:
> AustinMN wrote:
> > No
> > lawyer worth paying a cent for would ever admit anything to a cop (plea
> > bargans excepted), least of all intentionally hitting someone with a
> > car!
>
> Maybe an honest lawyer?


You know an honest lawyer? What is the definition of an honest lawyer?


Maggie.

David L. Johnson
June 9th 05, 06:51 PM
On Thu, 09 Jun 2005 06:17:56 -0700, AustinMN wrote:

> The cager in this proves the adage "Those who can't do, teach."

And those who can't teach, teach gym -- Woody Allen

> No
> lawyer worth paying a cent for would ever admit anything to a cop (plea
> bargans excepted), least of all intentionally hitting someone with a
> car!

If nothing else, she should be convicted for abject stupidity.

--

David L. Johnson

__o | Arguing with an engineer is like mud wrestling with a pig... You
_`\(,_ | soon find out the pig likes it!
(_)/ (_) |

catzz66
June 9th 05, 06:54 PM
Maggie wrote:
>
> You know an honest lawyer? What is the definition of an honest lawyer?
>
>
>

Yes. YOUR lawyer.

Rich
June 9th 05, 08:38 PM
AustinMN wrote:

> The cager in this proves the adage "Those who can't do, teach."

It might prove "At least one who can't do, teaches", but not "Those who
can't do, teach".

Dennis Ferguson
June 10th 05, 07:05 PM
Robert J. Matter wrote:
> A police officer testified Wednesday that Southern Methodist University
> law professor Jane Dolkart told him she only intended to tap a bicyclist
> with her car the day she allegedly ran him down.
>
> Officer Craig Bennight's testimony came on the first day of Ms.
> Dolkart's trial. She is charged with aggravated assault with a deadly
> weapon.

Is this a Texas thing? Note that this page

http://www.bicyclinglife.com/Library/TaleOfThree.htm

which compares the causes of bicycle-motor vehicle collisions in
Austin TX, Gainesville FL and Santa Barbara CA, has this comment:

Seven "Assault" incidents, the eighth ranking collision in Austin,
is extraordinarily high. Only one "Assault" was noted in Gainesville,
and none was found in Santa Barbara

Dennis Ferguson

AustinMN
June 12th 05, 05:09 AM
Dennis Ferguson wrote:
> Robert J. Matter wrote:
>> A police officer testified Wednesday that Southern Methodist University
>> law professor Jane Dolkart told him she only intended to tap a bicyclist
>> with her car the day she allegedly ran him down.
>>
>> Officer Craig Bennight's testimony came on the first day of Ms.
>> Dolkart's trial. She is charged with aggravated assault with a deadly
>> weapon.
>
> Is this a Texas thing? Note that this page
>
> http://www.bicyclinglife.com/Library/TaleOfThree.htm
>
> which compares the causes of bicycle-motor vehicle collisions in
> Austin TX, Gainesville FL and Santa Barbara CA, has this comment:
>
> Seven "Assault" incidents, the eighth ranking collision in Austin,
> is extraordinarily high. Only one "Assault" was noted in Gainesville,
> and none was found in Santa Barbara

It could be as much a Texas police interpretation thing as a Texas driver
thing.

Austin

Google

Payday Loans - Music Lyrics A to Z - Air Force 1 Shoes - Broadband - Utron Blog