CycleBanter.com

CycleBanter.com (http://www.cyclebanter.com/index.php)
-   Techniques (http://www.cyclebanter.com/forumdisplay.php?f=8)
-   -   Minnesota Winters (http://www.cyclebanter.com/showthread.php?t=198021)

Chris[_12_] December 13th 08 06:00 AM

Minnesota Winters
 
On Dec 12, 8:56*am, "Jeff Grippe" wrote:
I think that Tucson is rated #3 in some lists of top cities for cyclist.
Seattle, I believe, is #1 but I personally couldn't take the climate. With
all my various broken and repaired parts, I need dry. I understand that
Seattle is a fantastic place to live but its just not for me. Portland, I've
heard is also quite good but I have the same climate problems. So when I'm
ready to leave NY, I think I'll head to Tucson.
- Show quoted text -


I live in Seattle and moved here from Tucson. I can say that I would
rather ride bikes in Tucson for any one of a number of reasons. Tucson
streets are much wider even if there isn't a bike lane than Seattle
streets. Tucson is also much flatter than Seattle if you want it, but
you can still get hills if you want as well. The USPS Team trains
there climbing Mt Lemon. Tucson has less rain, but when it is raining,
I'd rather be in Seattle. The rain in Tucson is monsoon as a rule, and
is usually well over 1" an hour, whereas Seattle is pouring if it is
more than 1/2" an hour. Not to mention there is drainage for regular
rain in Seattle in the streets, but none in Tucson.

Then there is the sun and abundence of amazing Mexican food in Tucson.

I'll take the Tucson drivers too.

Chris

Chalo December 13th 08 09:45 AM

Minnesota Winters
 
Jeff Grippe wrote:

I live in Seattle and moved here from Tucson. I can say that I would
rather ride bikes in Tucson for any one of a number of reasons. Tucson
streets are much wider even if there isn't a bike lane than Seattle
streets. Tucson is also much flatter than Seattle if you want it, but
you can still get hills if you want as well. The USPS Team trains
there climbing Mt Lemon. Tucson has less rain, but when it is raining,
I'd rather be in Seattle. The rain in Tucson is monsoon as a rule, and
is usually well over 1" an hour, whereas Seattle is pouring if it is
more than 1/2" an hour. Not to mention there is drainage for regular
rain in Seattle in the streets, but none in Tucson.

Then there is the sun and abundence of amazing Mexican food in Tucson.

I'll take the Tucson drivers too.


I spent several years in Seattle before returning to my hometown of
Austin. My impression of cycling in the two cities is thus: It's
generally easier and better to ride bike in Austin. The terrain is a
lot more forgiving and the weather is loads better. But a lot more
people ride bike in Seattle, so all the social infrastructure is
better sorted out-- bike shops, bike clubs, bike events. There are
better bike paths around town. Even the car drivers in Seattle are
more prepared to deal with cyclists.

It's a funny coincidence that Austin and Seattle receive almost the
same amount of precipitation per year. Seattle gets it spread out
over 200 days or so. Austin seems to receive just a small handful of
awe-inspiring biblical deluges per year. When I moved to Seattle, I
was struck by how poorly worked out the street drainage was. In the
flatter areas it is common to have water pool up in the street. If
Austin had Seattle's storm drainage, people would die as a result.

The Mexican food situation in Seattle is dreary, but the Vietnamese
and Ethiopian food can't be beat. Don't waste the opportunity. These
are cuisines that few cities get exactly right.

If you ride the Burke-Gilman trail up to Bothell, surprisingly there
are a couple of decent Mexican restaurants right around where the B-G
ends and the Lake Sammamish Trail takes up. El Quetzal on Beacon Ave
is another excellent place to scratch your Mexican food itch.

Chalo

Jay Beattie December 13th 08 05:59 PM

Minnesota Winters
 
On Dec 13, 1:45*am, Chalo wrote:
Jeff Grippe wrote:

I live in Seattle and moved here from Tucson. I can say that I would
rather ride bikes in Tucson for any one of a number of reasons. Tucson
streets are much wider even if there isn't a bike lane than Seattle
streets. Tucson is also much flatter than Seattle if you want it, but
you can still get hills if you want as well. The USPS Team trains
there climbing Mt Lemon. Tucson has less rain, but when it is raining,
I'd rather be in Seattle. The rain in Tucson is monsoon as a rule, and
is usually well over 1" an hour, whereas Seattle is pouring if it is
more than 1/2" an hour. Not to mention there is drainage for regular
rain in Seattle in the streets, but none in Tucson.


Then there is the sun and abundence of amazing Mexican food in Tucson.


I'll take the Tucson drivers too.


I spent several years in Seattle before returning to my hometown of
Austin. *My impression of cycling in the two cities is thus: *It's
generally easier and better to ride bike in Austin. *The terrain is a
lot more forgiving and the weather is loads better. *But a lot more
people ride bike in Seattle, so all the social infrastructure is
better sorted out-- bike shops, bike clubs, bike events. *There are
better bike paths around town. *Even the car drivers in Seattle are
more prepared to deal with cyclists.

It's a funny coincidence that Austin and Seattle receive almost the
same amount of precipitation per year. *Seattle gets it spread out
over 200 days or so. *Austin seems to receive just a small handful of
awe-inspiring biblical deluges per year. *When I moved to Seattle, I
was struck by how poorly worked out the street drainage was. *In the
flatter areas it is common to have water pool up in the street. *If
Austin had Seattle's storm drainage, people would die as a result.

The Mexican food situation in Seattle is dreary, but the Vietnamese
and Ethiopian food can't be beat. *Don't waste the opportunity. *These
are cuisines that few cities get exactly right.

If you ride the Burke-Gilman trail up to Bothell, surprisingly there
are a couple of decent Mexican restaurants right around where the B-G
ends and the Lake Sammamish Trail takes up. *El Quetzal on Beacon Ave
is another excellent place to scratch your Mexican food itch.


What about the heat in Tucson? I have some experience riding in the
desert and found that it was impossible to ride in the summer sun, but
I'm not a big heat person, either. I don't like Seattle because of
the traffic; it is nice city to visit, but the weather is even more
dreary than PDX.

I was raised in the south SF Bay (Los Gatos), which has the perfect
weather and some of the best riding anywhere. I visit fairly
frequently, but I am always happy to get back to PDX for some reason.
I have grown accustomed to the seasons and all the trees and the pace
of life. It's nice to be back in the Republic of Portland with all the
bohemian wage earners and not a Ferrari in sight. Plus, I get to go
skiing every weekend -- starting probably next week, assuming no
problems with my new metal-filled leg. And as for Mexican food, we got
it, and if it has to be uber-authentic, you go down to one of those
joints in Woodburn where you're the only anglo in the place. -- Jay
Beattie.

Chris[_12_] December 14th 08 06:26 AM

Minnesota Winters
 
On Dec 13, 9:59*am, Jay Beattie wrote:
What about the heat in Tucson?
- Show quoted text -


In winter, it ranges between 60's during the day, to 40's or colder at
night. It's still very dry, so it is important to stay hydrated.

Chris

[email protected] December 15th 08 08:09 PM

Minnesota Winters
 
On Dec 14, 12:26*am, Chris wrote:
On Dec 13, 9:59*am, Jay Beattie wrote:

What about the heat in Tucson?
- Show quoted text -


In winter, it ranges between 60's during the day, to 40's or colder at
night. It's still very dry, so it is important to stay hydrated.

Chris


Sh--. High of 9 F today. Low of 5 below F. And there is a whole row
or two of states north of me so its almost balmy here.

Jay Beattie December 15th 08 11:25 PM

Minnesota Winters
 
On Dec 15, 12:09*pm, "
wrote:
On Dec 14, 12:26*am, Chris wrote:

On Dec 13, 9:59*am, Jay Beattie wrote:


What about the heat in Tucson?
- Show quoted text -


In winter, it ranges between 60's during the day, to 40's or colder at
night. It's still very dry, so it is important to stay hydrated.


Chris


Sh--. *High of 9 F today. *Low of 5 below F. *And there is a whole row
or two of states north of me so its almost balmy here.


I feel for you, really. We got snow over the weekend and are in the
middle of a cold snap -- but no where near single digits F. The snow
is only an inch or two downtown and has been reduced to sheet ice in
many places. I rode to work on my cross bike and had to get off and
walk in a couple of spots. I am going to have to pick my way home
until I get off the main roads and in to the hills. I can't gain too
much elevation, or else I'll be sledding home. I'm probably going to
have to drive tomorrow or take the bus.

On a somewhat tech note, I went to put on my (car) snow wheels on
Saturday, and my aluminum rims had welded to the iron hubs. Should
have used my anti-seize! Getting those mo-fos off was a monumental
PIA, but finally got it done. -- Jay Beattie.

Mark[_12_] December 16th 08 01:38 AM

Minnesota Winters
 
Jay Beattie wrote:
I feel for you, really. We got snow over the weekend and are in the
middle of a cold snap -- but no where near single digits F. The snow
is only an inch or two downtown and has been reduced to sheet ice in
many places. I rode to work on my cross bike and had to get off and
walk in a couple of spots. I am going to have to pick my way home
until I get off the main roads and in to the hills. I can't gain too
much elevation, or else I'll be sledding home. I'm probably going to
have to drive tomorrow or take the bus.

On a somewhat tech note, I went to put on my (car) snow wheels on
Saturday, [...]


Heh. Last night I put on my /bike/ snow wheels. Nokians work great:
http://www.icebike.org/Equipment/nokian106.htm

Tomorrow I gotta try a bit lower pressure, though. On the bike/ped
bridge facility, the footprints make hard-sided craters that you really
bounce through. Crossing the bridge is quite a pounding.

Mark J. - 50 miles south of Jay, with a lot less snow.

Tim McNamara December 16th 08 03:12 AM

Minnesota Winters
 
In article
,
" wrote:

On Dec 14, 12:26*am, Chris wrote:
On Dec 13, 9:59*am, Jay Beattie wrote:

What about the heat in Tucson? - Show quoted text -


In winter, it ranges between 60's during the day, to 40's or colder
at night. It's still very dry, so it is important to stay hydrated.

Chris


Sh--. High of 9 F today. Low of 5 below F. And there is a whole
row or two of states north of me so its almost balmy here.


-1F for the high today, -14F predicted for the low tonight, and the cold
part of the winter yet to come. Ed and I have finally found something
to agree on. Minnesota winters suck.

Jorg Lueke December 16th 08 03:17 AM

Minnesota Winters
 
On Dec 15, 9:12*pm, Tim McNamara wrote:
In article
,

" wrote:
On Dec 14, 12:26*am, Chris wrote:
On Dec 13, 9:59*am, Jay Beattie wrote:


What about the heat in Tucson? - Show quoted text -


In winter, it ranges between 60's during the day, to 40's or colder
at night. It's still very dry, so it is important to stay hydrated.


Chris


Sh--. *High of 9 F today. *Low of 5 below F. *And there is a whole
row or two of states north of me so its almost balmy here.


-1F for the high today, -14F predicted for the low tonight, and the cold
part of the winter yet to come. *Ed and I have finally found something
to agree on. *Minnesota winters suck.


It kills the bugs

Chalo December 16th 08 03:40 AM

Minnesota Winters
 
Jorg Lueke wrote:

Tim McNamara wrote:

-1F for the high today, -14F predicted for the low tonight, and the cold
part of the winter yet to come. *Ed and I have finally found something
to agree on. *Minnesota winters suck.


It kills the bugs


Here in Austin, we use Mexican Free-tailed bats for that.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congress_Avenue_Bridge

Chalo

max December 16th 08 04:20 AM

Minnesota Winters
 
In article
,
Chalo wrote:

Jorg Lueke wrote:

Tim McNamara wrote:

-1F for the high today, -14F predicted for the low tonight, and the cold
part of the winter yet to come. *Ed and I have finally found something
to agree on. *Minnesota winters suck.


It kills the bugs


Here in Austin, we use Mexican Free-tailed bats for that.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congress_Avenue_Bridge

Chalo


hey, that's pretty cool!

In the Contented People's Republic of Illinois, it was 7F today, with
very much ice on everything. I wouldn't want to have had to walk on what
i rode over. Hazardous for walking, the sheets of ice were crudittes*
for my Nokian's.

..max
*chicken nuggets in French

--
This signature can be appended to your outgoing mesages. Many people include in
their signatures contact information, and perhaps a joke or quotation.

Jay Beattie December 16th 08 06:59 PM

Minnesota Winters
 
On Dec 15, 5:38*pm, Mark wrote:
Jay Beattie wrote:
I feel for you, really. *We got snow over the weekend and are in the
middle of a cold snap -- but no where near single digits F. The snow
is only an inch or two downtown and has been reduced to sheet ice in
many places. I rode to work on my cross bike and had to get off and
walk in a couple of spots. I am going to have to pick my way home
until I get off the main roads and in to the hills. *I can't gain too
much elevation, or else I'll be sledding home. I'm probably going to
have to drive tomorrow or take the bus.


On a somewhat tech note, I went to put on my (car) snow wheels on
Saturday, [...]


Heh. *Last night I put on my /bike/ snow wheels. *Nokians work great:http://www.icebike.org/Equipment/nokian106.htm

Tomorrow I gotta try a bit lower pressure, though. *On the bike/ped
bridge facility, the footprints make hard-sided craters that you really
bounce through. *Crossing the bridge is quite a pounding.

Mark J. - 50 miles south of Jay, with a lot less snow.


Hey, I made it home last night on the sheet ice without any major
crashes, but I decided to take the plunge and buy some cheap studs
(Innova) from Bike Tires Direct (over near the airport) -- and after
my super-duper VIP discount, they were only about $26 a tire, which I
thought was not too terrible, even if I only use them a few times a
year. Beautiful blue skies today, but It's supposed to snow again
tomorrow, so I'll be really, really ready this time.

Last night, some guy yelled at me that I was supposed to be using
chains. I assume he was joking, but with all schoolmarmish behavior
towards bicyclists around here, I'm not quite sure. For you people
who see real winter weather, you would get a laugh out of the drivers
in PDX who panic over an inch or three of snow. The place practically
shuts down, and it turns to weather hysteria on the local news
channels.-- Jay Beattie.

[email protected] December 16th 08 07:42 PM

Minnesota Winters
 
There's more cold to winter in other places for which Carl Fogel
kindly found some URl's for a couple of ice.pps files that I had in my
collection of weather phenomena:

http://www.elanguages.org/files/42213
http://www.tom-phillips.info/powerpo...e.festival.pps

Jobst Brandt

A Muzi December 17th 08 12:24 AM

Minnesota Winters
 
wrote:
There's more cold to winter in other places for which Carl Fogel
kindly found some URl's for a couple of ice.pps files that I had in my
collection of weather phenomena:

http://www.elanguages.org/files/42213
http://www.tom-phillips.info/powerpo...e.festival.pps

Jobst Brandt


Winter riding you say? Make your travel arrangements now for the 2009
New Year's Ride:
http://www.yellowjersey.org/ny8.html

High Noon. No reservations, no registration fee, show-n-go.
--
Andrew Muzi
www.yellowjersey.org/
Open every day since 1 April, 1971
** Posted from http://www.teranews.com **

Jay Beattie December 17th 08 01:55 AM

Minnesota Winters
 
On Dec 16, 4:24*pm, A Muzi wrote:
wrote:
There's more cold to winter in other places for which Carl Fogel
kindly found some URl's for a couple of ice.pps files that I had in my
collection of weather phenomena:


*http://www.elanguages.org/files/42213
*http://www.tom-phillips.info/powerpo...ow.ice.festiva...


Jobst Brandt


Winter riding you say? Make your travel arrangements now for the 2009
New Year's Ride:http://www.yellowjersey.org/ny8.html

High Noon. No reservations, no registration fee, show-n-go.
--
Andrew Muzi
* www.yellowjersey.org/
* Open every day since 1 April, 1971
** Posted fromhttp://www.teranews.com**


Hey, Portland looked just like that (minus the snow drifts) on Monday
-- but with more ice patches. I got those Innova studs. That's a lot
of rubber -- they weigh about two pounds apiece. I'm going to give
them a whirl in the much anticipated snow storm tomorrow. --- Jay
Beattie.

jim beam December 17th 08 01:41 PM

Minnesota Winters
 
On Mon, 15 Dec 2008 15:25:07 -0800, Jay Beattie wrote:
snip for clarity
On a somewhat tech note, I went to put on my (car) snow wheels on
Saturday, and my aluminum rims had welded to the iron hubs. Should have
used my anti-seize! Getting those mo-fos off was a monumental PIA, but
finally got it done.


actually pretty easy to do this - simply loosen the lug nuts a couple of
turns, then go drive around the block. a couple of hard braking episodes
will break free the stubbornest of rusted wheels.

[email protected] December 17th 08 02:08 PM

Minnesota Winters
 
On Dec 17, 7:41*am, jim beam wrote:
On Mon, 15 Dec 2008 15:25:07 -0800, Jay Beattie wrote:

snip for clarity

On a somewhat tech note, I went to put on my (car) snow wheels on
Saturday, and my aluminum rims had welded to the iron hubs. *Should have
used my anti-seize! *Getting those mo-fos off was a monumental PIA, but
finally got it done.


actually pretty easy to do this - simply loosen the lug nuts a couple of
turns, then go drive around the block. *a couple of hard braking episodes
will break free the stubbornest of rusted wheels.


God Danged Jim. Thats the only intelligent thing you've ever posted
on this forum.

Jay Beattie December 17th 08 07:59 PM

Minnesota Winters
 
On Dec 17, 6:08*am, "
wrote:
On Dec 17, 7:41*am, jim beam wrote:

On Mon, 15 Dec 2008 15:25:07 -0800, Jay Beattie wrote:


snip for clarity


On a somewhat tech note, I went to put on my (car) snow wheels on
Saturday, and my aluminum rims had welded to the iron hubs. *Should have
used my anti-seize! *Getting those mo-fos off was a monumental PIA, but
finally got it done.


actually pretty easy to do this - simply loosen the lug nuts a couple of
turns, then go drive around the block. *a couple of hard braking episodes
will break free the stubbornest of rusted wheels.


God Danged Jim. *Thats the only intelligent thing you've ever posted
on this forum.


I did that, and it worked with the front wheel but not the rear
wheel. I had to take additional measures for the rear wheel,
including putting some Liquid Wrench between the rim and hub and
engaging in the telephone book rhumba -- you loosen the lug nuts and
then drive the stuck wheel over a phone book, back and forth. Then
you kick the wheel in strategic locations. That finally worked. Or
maybe it was the swearing that did it.

Anyway, I rode to work on my new, cheap-o Innova ice tires today. Not
going to win any races on those fatties, but, wow, they really do work
well on ice. I was getting a little too cocky and almost wiped out.
They are not good on dry pavement, though. They squirm and float
quite a bit, and the tread is not that straight -- or else it looks
crooked because the tires are slowly blowing off my svelt Open Pros.
That happened when I was blowing one up, but the tube is so beefy that
at 60psi, a 4" section just bulged out and sat there.

It's near white-out looking out my office window, so I guess I will
have plenty of fresh snow and ice for the ride home.-- Jay Beattie.

..

Clive George December 17th 08 09:52 PM

Minnesota Winters
 
"Jay Beattie" wrote in message
...
On Dec 17, 6:08 am, "
wrote:
On Dec 17, 7:41 am, jim beam wrote:

On Mon, 15 Dec 2008 15:25:07 -0800, Jay Beattie wrote:


snip for clarity


On a somewhat tech note, I went to put on my (car) snow wheels on
Saturday, and my aluminum rims had welded to the iron hubs. Should
have
used my anti-seize! Getting those mo-fos off was a monumental PIA,
but
finally got it done.


actually pretty easy to do this - simply loosen the lug nuts a couple
of
turns, then go drive around the block. a couple of hard braking
episodes
will break free the stubbornest of rusted wheels.


God Danged Jim. Thats the only intelligent thing you've ever posted
on this forum.


I did that, and it worked with the front wheel but not the rear
wheel. I had to take additional measures for the rear wheel,
including putting some Liquid Wrench between the rim and hub and
engaging in the telephone book rhumba -- you loosen the lug nuts and
then drive the stuck wheel over a phone book, back and forth. Then
you kick the wheel in strategic locations. That finally worked. Or
maybe it was the swearing that did it.


My 4lb club hammer was bought specifically to remove a wheel from my car.
I'd tried the 1lb one, no joy, no matter how hard I went at it. 4lb one,
smack, wheel off.



[email protected] December 17th 08 10:15 PM

Minnesota Winters
 
On Dec 17, 1:59*pm, Jay Beattie wrote:
On Dec 17, 6:08*am, "





wrote:
On Dec 17, 7:41*am, jim beam wrote:


On Mon, 15 Dec 2008 15:25:07 -0800, Jay Beattie wrote:


snip for clarity


On a somewhat tech note, I went to put on my (car) snow wheels on
Saturday, and my aluminum rims had welded to the iron hubs. *Should have
used my anti-seize! *Getting those mo-fos off was a monumental PIA, but
finally got it done.


actually pretty easy to do this - simply loosen the lug nuts a couple of
turns, then go drive around the block. *a couple of hard braking episodes
will break free the stubbornest of rusted wheels.


God Danged Jim. *Thats the only intelligent thing you've ever posted
on this forum.


I did that, and it worked with the front wheel but not the rear
wheel. *I had to take additional measures for the rear wheel,
including putting some Liquid Wrench between the rim and hub and
engaging in the telephone book rhumba -- you loosen the lug nuts and
then drive the stuck wheel over a phone book, back and forth. *Then
you kick the wheel in strategic locations. *That finally worked. Or
maybe it was the swearing that did it.

Anyway, I rode to work on my new, cheap-o Innova ice tires today. *Not
going to win any races on those fatties, but, wow, they really do work
well on ice. *I was getting a little too cocky and almost wiped out.
They are not good on dry pavement, though. *They squirm and float
quite a bit, and the tread is not that straight -- or else it looks
crooked because the tires are slowly blowing off my svelt Open Pros.
That happened when I was blowing one up, but the tube is so beefy that
at 60psi, a 4" section just bulged out and sat there.

*It's *near white-out looking out my office window, so I guess I will
have plenty of fresh snow and ice for the ride home.-- Jay Beattie.

.- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


I'm using my new Schwalbe Marathon Winter 700x35 studded tires. They
ride perfectly fine on dry pavement. In loose snow, such as on the
side of the road after the cars have pounded it for awhile, they can
get squirrely. Ice or dry pavement, great traction. They are slower
than regular tires. Partly because I only put 35 psi in them to allow
them to flatten out as much as possible and get all 4 rows of studs in
contact with the ground.

http://www.amazon.com/Schwalbe-Marat...9551993&sr=1-2

http://www.peterwhitecycles.com/studdedtires.asp


Jay Beattie December 17th 08 10:31 PM

Minnesota Winters
 
On Dec 17, 2:15*pm, "
wrote:
On Dec 17, 1:59*pm, Jay Beattie wrote:





On Dec 17, 6:08*am, "


wrote:
On Dec 17, 7:41*am, jim beam wrote:


On Mon, 15 Dec 2008 15:25:07 -0800, Jay Beattie wrote:


snip for clarity


On a somewhat tech note, I went to put on my (car) snow wheels on
Saturday, and my aluminum rims had welded to the iron hubs. *Should have
used my anti-seize! *Getting those mo-fos off was a monumental PIA, but
finally got it done.


actually pretty easy to do this - simply loosen the lug nuts a couple of
turns, then go drive around the block. *a couple of hard braking episodes
will break free the stubbornest of rusted wheels.


God Danged Jim. *Thats the only intelligent thing you've ever posted
on this forum.


I did that, and it worked with the front wheel but not the rear
wheel. *I had to take additional measures for the rear wheel,
including putting some Liquid Wrench between the rim and hub and
engaging in the telephone book rhumba -- you loosen the lug nuts and
then drive the stuck wheel over a phone book, back and forth. *Then
you kick the wheel in strategic locations. *That finally worked. Or
maybe it was the swearing that did it.


Anyway, I rode to work on my new, cheap-o Innova ice tires today. *Not
going to win any races on those fatties, but, wow, they really do work
well on ice. *I was getting a little too cocky and almost wiped out.
They are not good on dry pavement, though. *They squirm and float
quite a bit, and the tread is not that straight -- or else it looks
crooked because the tires are slowly blowing off my svelt Open Pros.
That happened when I was blowing one up, but the tube is so beefy that
at 60psi, a 4" section just bulged out and sat there.


*It's *near white-out looking out my office window, so I guess I will
have plenty of fresh snow and ice for the ride home.-- Jay Beattie.


.- Hide quoted text -


- Show quoted text -


I'm using my new Schwalbe Marathon Winter 700x35 studded tires. *They
ride perfectly fine on dry pavement. *In loose snow, such as on the
side of the road after the cars have pounded it for awhile, they can
get squirrely. *Ice or dry pavement, great traction. *They are slower
than regular tires. *Partly because I only put 35 psi in them to allow
them to flatten out as much as possible and get all 4 rows of studs in
contact with the ground.

http://www.amazon.com/Schwalbe-Marat...ck/dp/B00113L8...

http://www.peterwhitecycles.com/studdedtires.asp- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


Those Schwalbe look mighty nice (I have the Schwalbe Blizzards on this
bike for ordinary riding), but they are two to three times the price I
paid for my beater Innovas. If I lived in Minnesota, I might make the
investment. Bike Tires Direct has a whole slew of ice tires including
the Schwalbe. http://www.biketiresdirect.com/searc...?ss=330&cat=su

I just felt that in these tough economic times, I should support
Chinese industry. And melamine gives me added grip on ice. -- Jay
Beattie.

Kerry Montgomery December 17th 08 11:25 PM

Minnesota Winters
 

"Jay Beattie" wrote in message
...
On Dec 17, 2:15 pm, "
wrote:
On Dec 17, 1:59 pm, Jay Beattie wrote:





On Dec 17, 6:08 am, "


wrote:
On Dec 17, 7:41 am, jim beam wrote:


On Mon, 15 Dec 2008 15:25:07 -0800, Jay Beattie wrote:


snip for clarity


On a somewhat tech note, I went to put on my (car) snow wheels on
Saturday, and my aluminum rims had welded to the iron hubs. Should
have
used my anti-seize! Getting those mo-fos off was a monumental PIA,
but
finally got it done.


actually pretty easy to do this - simply loosen the lug nuts a
couple of
turns, then go drive around the block. a couple of hard braking
episodes
will break free the stubbornest of rusted wheels.


God Danged Jim. Thats the only intelligent thing you've ever posted
on this forum.


I did that, and it worked with the front wheel but not the rear
wheel. I had to take additional measures for the rear wheel,
including putting some Liquid Wrench between the rim and hub and
engaging in the telephone book rhumba -- you loosen the lug nuts and
then drive the stuck wheel over a phone book, back and forth. Then
you kick the wheel in strategic locations. That finally worked. Or
maybe it was the swearing that did it.


Anyway, I rode to work on my new, cheap-o Innova ice tires today. Not
going to win any races on those fatties, but, wow, they really do work
well on ice. I was getting a little too cocky and almost wiped out.
They are not good on dry pavement, though. They squirm and float
quite a bit, and the tread is not that straight -- or else it looks
crooked because the tires are slowly blowing off my svelt Open Pros.
That happened when I was blowing one up, but the tube is so beefy that
at 60psi, a 4" section just bulged out and sat there.


It's near white-out looking out my office window, so I guess I will
have plenty of fresh snow and ice for the ride home.-- Jay Beattie.


.- Hide quoted text -


- Show quoted text -


I'm using my new Schwalbe Marathon Winter 700x35 studded tires. They
ride perfectly fine on dry pavement. In loose snow, such as on the
side of the road after the cars have pounded it for awhile, they can
get squirrely. Ice or dry pavement, great traction. They are slower
than regular tires. Partly because I only put 35 psi in them to allow
them to flatten out as much as possible and get all 4 rows of studs in
contact with the ground.

http://www.amazon.com/Schwalbe-Marat...ck/dp/B00113L8...

http://www.peterwhitecycles.com/studdedtires.asp- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


Those Schwalbe look mighty nice (I have the Schwalbe Blizzards on this
bike for ordinary riding), but they are two to three times the price I
paid for my beater Innovas. If I lived in Minnesota, I might make the
investment. Bike Tires Direct has a whole slew of ice tires including
the Schwalbe.
http://www.biketiresdirect.com/searc...?ss=330&cat=su

I just felt that in these tough economic times, I should support
Chinese industry. And melamine gives me added grip on ice. -- Jay
Beattie.


Jay,
"...slew of ice tires..." gave me a good laugh, thanks,
Kerry



Jay Beattie December 18th 08 03:46 AM

Minnesota Winters
 
On Dec 17, 3:25*pm, "Kerry Montgomery" wrote:
"Jay Beattie" wrote in message

...
On Dec 17, 2:15 pm, "





wrote:
On Dec 17, 1:59 pm, Jay Beattie wrote:


On Dec 17, 6:08 am, "


wrote:
On Dec 17, 7:41 am, jim beam wrote:


On Mon, 15 Dec 2008 15:25:07 -0800, Jay Beattie wrote:


snip for clarity


On a somewhat tech note, I went to put on my (car) snow wheels on
Saturday, and my aluminum rims had welded to the iron hubs. Should
have
used my anti-seize! Getting those mo-fos off was a monumental PIA,
but
finally got it done.


actually pretty easy to do this - simply loosen the lug nuts a
couple of
turns, then go drive around the block. a couple of hard braking
episodes
will break free the stubbornest of rusted wheels.


God Danged Jim. Thats the only intelligent thing you've ever posted
on this forum.


I did that, and it worked with the front wheel but not the rear
wheel. I had to take additional measures for the rear wheel,
including putting some Liquid Wrench between the rim and hub and
engaging in the telephone book rhumba -- you loosen the lug nuts and
then drive the stuck wheel over a phone book, back and forth. Then
you kick the wheel in strategic locations. That finally worked. Or
maybe it was the swearing that did it.


Anyway, I rode to work on my new, cheap-o Innova ice tires today. Not
going to win any races on those fatties, but, wow, they really do work
well on ice. I was getting a little too cocky and almost wiped out.
They are not good on dry pavement, though. They squirm and float
quite a bit, and the tread is not that straight -- or else it looks
crooked because the tires are slowly blowing off my svelt Open Pros.
That happened when I was blowing one up, but the tube is so beefy that
at 60psi, a 4" section just bulged out and sat there.


It's near white-out looking out my office window, so I guess I will
have plenty of fresh snow and ice for the ride home.-- Jay Beattie.


.- Hide quoted text -


- Show quoted text -


I'm using my new Schwalbe Marathon Winter 700x35 studded tires. They
ride perfectly fine on dry pavement. In loose snow, such as on the
side of the road after the cars have pounded it for awhile, they can
get squirrely. Ice or dry pavement, great traction. They are slower
than regular tires. Partly because I only put 35 psi in them to allow
them to flatten out as much as possible and get all 4 rows of studs in
contact with the ground.


http://www.amazon.com/Schwalbe-Marat...ck/dp/B00113L8...


http://www.peterwhitecycles.com/studdedtires.asp-Hide quoted text -


- Show quoted text -


Those Schwalbe look mighty nice (I have the Schwalbe Blizzards on this
bike for ordinary riding), but they are two to three times the price I
paid for my beater Innovas. *If I lived in Minnesota, I might make the
investment. Bike Tires Direct has a whole slew of ice tires including
the Schwalbe.http://www.biketiresdirect.com/searc...?ss=330&cat=su

I just felt that in these tough economic times, I should support
Chinese industry. And melamine gives me added grip on ice. -- Jay
Beattie.

Jay,
"...slew of ice tires..." gave me a good laugh, thanks,
Kerry- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


Not a slew? Hey, I was happy they had two for me. Those tires were
great for riding home tonight in the epic snow storm (which seemed a
lot like the usual rain storm). News at 6,7,8,9,10 . . . -- Jay
Beattie.

[email protected] December 18th 08 04:42 PM

Minnesota Winters
 
On Dec 17, 4:31*pm, Jay Beattie wrote:
On Dec 17, 2:15*pm, "





wrote:
On Dec 17, 1:59*pm, Jay Beattie wrote:


On Dec 17, 6:08*am, "


wrote:
On Dec 17, 7:41*am, jim beam wrote:


On Mon, 15 Dec 2008 15:25:07 -0800, Jay Beattie wrote:


snip for clarity


On a somewhat tech note, I went to put on my (car) snow wheels on
Saturday, and my aluminum rims had welded to the iron hubs. *Should have
used my anti-seize! *Getting those mo-fos off was a monumental PIA, but
finally got it done.


actually pretty easy to do this - simply loosen the lug nuts a couple of
turns, then go drive around the block. *a couple of hard braking episodes
will break free the stubbornest of rusted wheels.


God Danged Jim. *Thats the only intelligent thing you've ever posted
on this forum.


I did that, and it worked with the front wheel but not the rear
wheel. *I had to take additional measures for the rear wheel,
including putting some Liquid Wrench between the rim and hub and
engaging in the telephone book rhumba -- you loosen the lug nuts and
then drive the stuck wheel over a phone book, back and forth. *Then
you kick the wheel in strategic locations. *That finally worked. Or
maybe it was the swearing that did it.


Anyway, I rode to work on my new, cheap-o Innova ice tires today. *Not
going to win any races on those fatties, but, wow, they really do work
well on ice. *I was getting a little too cocky and almost wiped out..
They are not good on dry pavement, though. *They squirm and float
quite a bit, and the tread is not that straight -- or else it looks
crooked because the tires are slowly blowing off my svelt Open Pros.
That happened when I was blowing one up, but the tube is so beefy that
at 60psi, a 4" section just bulged out and sat there.


*It's *near white-out looking out my office window, so I guess I will
have plenty of fresh snow and ice for the ride home.-- Jay Beattie.


.- Hide quoted text -


- Show quoted text -


I'm using my new Schwalbe Marathon Winter 700x35 studded tires. *They
ride perfectly fine on dry pavement. *In loose snow, such as on the
side of the road after the cars have pounded it for awhile, they can
get squirrely. *Ice or dry pavement, great traction. *They are slower
than regular tires. *Partly because I only put 35 psi in them to allow
them to flatten out as much as possible and get all 4 rows of studs in
contact with the ground.


http://www.amazon.com/Schwalbe-Marat...ck/dp/B00113L8...


http://www.peterwhitecycles.com/studdedtires.asp-Hide quoted text -


- Show quoted text -


Those Schwalbe look mighty nice (I have the Schwalbe Blizzards on this
bike for ordinary riding), but they are two to three times the price I
paid for my beater Innovas. *If I lived in Minnesota, I might make the
investment. Bike Tires Direct has a whole slew of ice tires including
the Schwalbe.http://www.biketiresdirect.com/searc...?ss=330&cat=su

I just felt that in these tough economic times, I should support
Chinese industry. And melamine gives me added grip on ice. -- Jay
Beattie.- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


Twice the price. But over twice the studs. 240 compared to 110.
Carbide instead of carbon steel. They are the most expensive bike
tires I've ever bought.

Jay Beattie December 18th 08 05:33 PM

Minnesota Winters
 
On Dec 18, 8:42*am, "
wrote:
On Dec 17, 4:31*pm, Jay Beattie wrote:





On Dec 17, 2:15*pm, "


wrote:
On Dec 17, 1:59*pm, Jay Beattie wrote:


On Dec 17, 6:08*am, "


wrote:
On Dec 17, 7:41*am, jim beam wrote:


On Mon, 15 Dec 2008 15:25:07 -0800, Jay Beattie wrote:


snip for clarity


On a somewhat tech note, I went to put on my (car) snow wheels on
Saturday, and my aluminum rims had welded to the iron hubs. *Should have
used my anti-seize! *Getting those mo-fos off was a monumental PIA, but
finally got it done.


actually pretty easy to do this - simply loosen the lug nuts a couple of
turns, then go drive around the block. *a couple of hard braking episodes
will break free the stubbornest of rusted wheels.


God Danged Jim. *Thats the only intelligent thing you've ever posted
on this forum.


I did that, and it worked with the front wheel but not the rear
wheel. *I had to take additional measures for the rear wheel,
including putting some Liquid Wrench between the rim and hub and
engaging in the telephone book rhumba -- you loosen the lug nuts and
then drive the stuck wheel over a phone book, back and forth. *Then
you kick the wheel in strategic locations. *That finally worked. Or
maybe it was the swearing that did it.


Anyway, I rode to work on my new, cheap-o Innova ice tires today. *Not
going to win any races on those fatties, but, wow, they really do work
well on ice. *I was getting a little too cocky and almost wiped out.
They are not good on dry pavement, though. *They squirm and float
quite a bit, and the tread is not that straight -- or else it looks
crooked because the tires are slowly blowing off my svelt Open Pros..
That happened when I was blowing one up, but the tube is so beefy that
at 60psi, a 4" section just bulged out and sat there.


*It's *near white-out looking out my office window, so I guess I will
have plenty of fresh snow and ice for the ride home.-- Jay Beattie.


.- Hide quoted text -


- Show quoted text -


I'm using my new Schwalbe Marathon Winter 700x35 studded tires. *They
ride perfectly fine on dry pavement. *In loose snow, such as on the
side of the road after the cars have pounded it for awhile, they can
get squirrely. *Ice or dry pavement, great traction. *They are slower
than regular tires. *Partly because I only put 35 psi in them to allow
them to flatten out as much as possible and get all 4 rows of studs in
contact with the ground.


http://www.amazon.com/Schwalbe-Marat...ck/dp/B00113L8....


http://www.peterwhitecycles.com/stud...asp-Hidequoted text -


- Show quoted text -


Those Schwalbe look mighty nice (I have the Schwalbe Blizzards on this
bike for ordinary riding), but they are two to three times the price I
paid for my beater Innovas. *If I lived in Minnesota, I might make the
investment. Bike Tires Direct has a whole slew of ice tires including
the Schwalbe.http://www.biketiresdirect.com/searc...?ss=330&cat=su


I just felt that in these tough economic times, I should support
Chinese industry. And melamine gives me added grip on ice. -- Jay
Beattie.- Hide quoted text -


- Show quoted text -


Twice the price. *But over twice the studs. *240 compared to 110.
Carbide instead of carbon steel. *They are the most expensive bike
tires I've ever bought.- Hide quoted text -


The steel quality is important, although I'll be dead before I wear
these things out with the number of days per year I expect to use
them. I think carbide would be a must have in Minnesota.

What I wonder about and could read-up on (if I were to move to
Minnesota) is tread pattern and stud number. Some of the Nokians have
less studs than my Innovas, and the Schwalbes and other Nokians have
more studs but a less aggressive tread pattern. Peter White explains
some of these design choices and gives reasons for choosing one design
over another -- and a serious purchaser would really have to think
about where, when and how he or she intends to ride.

I would also be curious to find out what tire has the best float in
slush and till, since that is where I have most of my troubles on the
Innovas. Ice is no problem, and on packed snow, I could ride my
regular Hutchinson cross tires. In the till, though, I fish-tail
badly, which is disconcerting with cars passing nearby. -- Jay Beattie.

jim beam December 19th 08 06:02 AM

Minnesota Winters
 
On Wed, 17 Dec 2008 06:08:00 -0800, wrote:

On Dec 17, 7:41Â*am, jim beam wrote:
On Mon, 15 Dec 2008 15:25:07 -0800, Jay Beattie wrote:

snip for clarity

On a somewhat tech note, I went to put on my (car) snow wheels on
Saturday, and my aluminum rims had welded to the iron hubs. Â*Should
have used my anti-seize! Â*Getting those mo-fos off was a monumental
PIA, but finally got it done.


actually pretty easy to do this - simply loosen the lug nuts a couple
of turns, then go drive around the block. Â*a couple of hard braking
episodes will break free the stubbornest of rusted wheels.


God Danged Jim. Thats the only intelligent thing you've ever posted on
this forum.



translation: "that's the only thing accessible to troglodytes like me".

carry on russell. maybe one day, you'll spot something else sufficiently
obvious and lowbrow to be understandable.


jim beam December 19th 08 06:02 AM

Minnesota Winters
 
On Wed, 17 Dec 2008 21:52:56 +0000, Clive George wrote:

"Jay Beattie" wrote in message
...
On Dec 17, 6:08 am, "
wrote:
On Dec 17, 7:41 am, jim beam wrote:

On Mon, 15 Dec 2008 15:25:07 -0800, Jay Beattie wrote:

snip for clarity

On a somewhat tech note, I went to put on my (car) snow wheels on
Saturday, and my aluminum rims had welded to the iron hubs. Should
have
used my anti-seize! Getting those mo-fos off was a monumental PIA,
but
finally got it done.

actually pretty easy to do this - simply loosen the lug nuts a
couple of
turns, then go drive around the block. a couple of hard braking
episodes
will break free the stubbornest of rusted wheels.

God Danged Jim. Thats the only intelligent thing you've ever posted on
this forum.


I did that, and it worked with the front wheel but not the rear wheel.
I had to take additional measures for the rear wheel, including putting
some Liquid Wrench between the rim and hub and engaging in the telephone
book rhumba -- you loosen the lug nuts and then drive the stuck wheel
over a phone book, back and forth. Then you kick the wheel in strategic
locations. That finally worked. Or maybe it was the swearing that did
it.


My 4lb club hammer was bought specifically to remove a wheel from my
car. I'd tried the 1lb one, no joy, no matter how hard I went at it. 4lb
one, smack, wheel off.


smack. brinelled bearings. specifically unjoyous deployment of a 4lb
hammer when the car's own function can serve the purpose, and not damage
anything.

Tim McNamara December 19th 08 06:21 AM

Minnesota Winters
 
In article
,
Jay Beattie wrote:

On Dec 18, 8:42*am, "
wrote:
On Dec 17, 4:31*pm, Jay Beattie wrote:





On Dec 17, 2:15*pm, "


wrote:
On Dec 17, 1:59*pm, Jay Beattie
wrote:


On Dec 17, 6:08*am, "


wrote:
On Dec 17, 7:41*am, jim beam
wrote:


On Mon, 15 Dec 2008 15:25:07 -0800, Jay Beattie wrote:


snip for clarity


On a somewhat tech note, I went to put on my (car) snow
wheels on Saturday, and my aluminum rims had welded to
the iron hubs. *Should have used my anti-seize!
*Getting those mo-fos off was a monumental PIA, but
finally got it done.


actually pretty easy to do this - simply loosen the lug
nuts a couple of turns, then go drive around the block.
*a couple of hard braking episodes will break free the
stubbornest of rusted wheels.


God Danged Jim. *Thats the only intelligent thing you've
ever posted on this forum.


I did that, and it worked with the front wheel but not the
rear wheel. *I had to take additional measures for the rear
wheel, including putting some Liquid Wrench between the rim
and hub and engaging in the telephone book rhumba -- you
loosen the lug nuts and then drive the stuck wheel over a
phone book, back and forth. *Then you kick the wheel in
strategic locations. *That finally worked. Or maybe it was
the swearing that did it.


Anyway, I rode to work on my new, cheap-o Innova ice tires
today. *Not going to win any races on those fatties, but,
wow, they really do work well on ice. *I was getting a little
too cocky and almost wiped out. They are not good on dry
pavement, though. *They squirm and float quite a bit, and the
tread is not that straight -- or else it looks crooked
because the tires are slowly blowing off my svelt Open Pros.
That happened when I was blowing one up, but the tube is so
beefy that at 60psi, a 4" section just bulged out and sat
there.


*It's *near white-out looking out my office window, so I
guess I will have plenty of fresh snow and ice for the ride
home.-- Jay Beattie.


.- Hide quoted text -


- Show quoted text -


I'm using my new Schwalbe Marathon Winter 700x35 studded tires.
*They ride perfectly fine on dry pavement. *In loose snow, such
as on the side of the road after the cars have pounded it for
awhile, they can get squirrely. *Ice or dry pavement, great
traction. *They are slower than regular tires. *Partly because
I only put 35 psi in them to allow them to flatten out as much
as possible and get all 4 rows of studs in contact with the
ground.


http://www.amazon.com/Schwalbe-Marat...-Black/dp/B001
13L8...


http://www.peterwhitecycles.com/stud...asp-Hidequoted text
-


- Show quoted text -


Those Schwalbe look mighty nice (I have the Schwalbe Blizzards on
this bike for ordinary riding), but they are two to three times
the price I paid for my beater Innovas. *If I lived in Minnesota,
I might make the investment. Bike Tires Direct has a whole slew
of ice tires including the
Schwalbe.http://www.biketiresdirect.com/searc...ts.asp?ss=330&
cat=su


I just felt that in these tough economic times, I should support
Chinese industry. And melamine gives me added grip on ice. -- Jay
Beattie.- Hide quoted text -


- Show quoted text -


Twice the price. *But over twice the studs. *240 compared to 110.
Carbide instead of carbon steel. *They are the most expensive bike
tires I've ever bought.- Hide quoted text -


The steel quality is important, although I'll be dead before I wear
these things out with the number of days per year I expect to use
them. I think carbide would be a must have in Minnesota


There are other options, such as the famed "Gossamer Walrus:"

http://www.velomobiling.com/gallery/...s/IceBike2007/

With video:

http://velomobiling.blogspot.com/200...ce-biking.html

http://www.calhouncycle.com/events/i...01icehome.html

Clive George December 19th 08 01:21 PM

Minnesota Winters
 
"jim beam" wrote in message
...

actually pretty easy to do this - simply loosen the lug nuts a
couple of
turns, then go drive around the block. a couple of hard braking
episodes
will break free the stubbornest of rusted wheels.

God Danged Jim. Thats the only intelligent thing you've ever posted on
this forum.

I did that, and it worked with the front wheel but not the rear wheel.
I had to take additional measures for the rear wheel, including putting
some Liquid Wrench between the rim and hub and engaging in the telephone
book rhumba -- you loosen the lug nuts and then drive the stuck wheel
over a phone book, back and forth. Then you kick the wheel in strategic
locations. That finally worked. Or maybe it was the swearing that did
it.


My 4lb club hammer was bought specifically to remove a wheel from my
car. I'd tried the 1lb one, no joy, no matter how hard I went at it. 4lb
one, smack, wheel off.


smack. brinelled bearings. specifically unjoyous deployment of a 4lb
hammer when the car's own function can serve the purpose, and not damage
anything.


And what sort of loads + impacts do the bearings get in normal use? What
impacts do they get when you're driving around with loose nuts? You're
raising bogus worries.



Tim McNamara December 19th 08 04:10 PM

Minnesota Winters
 
In article ,
"Clive George" wrote:

"jim beam" wrote in message
...

actually pretty easy to do this - simply loosen the lug nuts a
couple of turns, then go drive around the block. a couple of
hard braking episodes will break free the stubbornest of
rusted wheels.

God Danged Jim. Thats the only intelligent thing you've ever
posted on this forum.

I did that, and it worked with the front wheel but not the rear
wheel. I had to take additional measures for the rear wheel,
including putting some Liquid Wrench between the rim and hub and
engaging in the telephone book rhumba -- you loosen the lug nuts
and then drive the stuck wheel over a phone book, back and forth.
Then you kick the wheel in strategic locations. That finally
worked. Or maybe it was the swearing that did it.

My 4lb club hammer was bought specifically to remove a wheel from
my car. I'd tried the 1lb one, no joy, no matter how hard I went
at it. 4lb one, smack, wheel off.


smack. brinelled bearings. specifically unjoyous deployment of a
4lb hammer when the car's own function can serve the purpose, and
not damage anything.


And what sort of loads + impacts do the bearings get in normal use?
What impacts do they get when you're driving around with loose nuts?
You're raising bogus worries.


Not our jim!

Tom Sherman[_2_] December 21st 08 06:24 AM

Bearing damage?
 
"jim beam" wrote:
On Wed, 17 Dec 2008 21:52:56 +0000, Clive George wrote:

"Jay Beattie" wrote in message
...
On Dec 17, 6:08 am, "
wrote:
On Dec 17, 7:41 am, jim beam wrote:

On Mon, 15 Dec 2008 15:25:07 -0800, Jay Beattie wrote:
snip for clarity
On a somewhat tech note, I went to put on my (car) snow wheels on
Saturday, and my aluminum rims had welded to the iron hubs. Should
have
used my anti-seize! Getting those mo-fos off was a monumental PIA,
but
finally got it done.
actually pretty easy to do this - simply loosen the lug nuts a
couple of
turns, then go drive around the block. a couple of hard braking
episodes
will break free the stubbornest of rusted wheels.
God Danged Jim. Thats the only intelligent thing you've ever posted on
this forum.
I did that, and it worked with the front wheel but not the rear wheel.
I had to take additional measures for the rear wheel, including putting
some Liquid Wrench between the rim and hub and engaging in the telephone
book rhumba -- you loosen the lug nuts and then drive the stuck wheel
over a phone book, back and forth. Then you kick the wheel in strategic
locations. That finally worked. Or maybe it was the swearing that did
it.

My 4lb club hammer was bought specifically to remove a wheel from my
car. I'd tried the 1lb one, no joy, no matter how hard I went at it. 4lb
one, smack, wheel off.


smack. brinelled bearings. specifically unjoyous deployment of a 4lb
hammer when the car's own function can serve the purpose, and not damage
anything.


How come bottom bracket bearing do NOT have this problem when a hammer
is used to drive cotter pins in [1] and out on cranks?

[1] No, tightening is NOT done with the nut with attaching a cottered crank.

--
Tom Sherman - 42.435731,-83.985007
LOCAL CACTUS EATS CYCLIST - datakoll

Tom Keats December 21st 08 06:35 AM

Bearing damage?
 
In article ,
Tom Sherman writes:

smack. brinelled bearings. specifically unjoyous deployment of a 4lb
hammer when the car's own function can serve the purpose, and not damage
anything.


How come bottom bracket bearing do NOT have this problem when a hammer
is used to drive cotter pins in [1] and out on cranks?

[1] No, tightening is NOT done with the nut with attaching a cottered crank.


When cotter pins have to be pounded in, there's
something horribly wrong. It usually happens
from the bike shop who doesn't quite have the
exact match of what you require, and gives you
what they consider the next closest thing.
It's an all too common occurance.

Anyways, bearings get ruined by being used
dry of grease/lubricant.

cheers,
Tom

--
Nothing is safe from me.
I'm really at:
tkeats curlicue vcn dot bc dot ca

[email protected] December 21st 08 07:01 AM

Bearing damage?
 
Tom Keats wrote:

smack. Brinelled bearings. specifically unjoyous deployment of a
4lb hammer when the car's own function can serve the purpose, and
not damage anything.


How come bottom bracket bearing do NOT have this problem when a
hammer is used to drive cotter pins in [1] and out on cranks?


[1] No, tightening is NOT done with the nut with attaching a
cottered crank.


When cotter pins have to be pounded in, there's something horribly
wrong. It usually happens from the bike shop who doesn't quite have
the exact match of what you require, and gives you what they
consider the next closest thing. It's an all too common occurrence.


Anyway, bearings get ruined by being used dry of grease/lubricant.


I'd like to hear more about that. Who rides with lubricant free BB
bearings? Besides, no matter how you brace the spindle when pounding
in cotters, the shock reaches the ball or two under the spindle. In
addition, I saw many cranks secured without more than a 1/2 lb hammer
held under the crank, yet no dents in the spindle resulted.

I still have cottered crank spindles lying around that have no sign of
Brinelling although I have a few head sets where both top and bottom
ball bearings as well a roller bearing ones have fretting dimples.

Jobst Brandt

Tom Keats December 21st 08 07:24 AM

Bearing damage?
 
In article ,
writes:
Tom Keats wrote:

smack. Brinelled bearings. specifically unjoyous deployment of a
4lb hammer when the car's own function can serve the purpose, and
not damage anything.


How come bottom bracket bearing do NOT have this problem when a
hammer is used to drive cotter pins in [1] and out on cranks?


[1] No, tightening is NOT done with the nut with attaching a
cottered crank.


When cotter pins have to be pounded in, there's something horribly
wrong. It usually happens from the bike shop who doesn't quite have
the exact match of what you require, and gives you what they
consider the next closest thing. It's an all too common occurrence.


Anyway, bearings get ruined by being used dry of grease/lubricant.


I'd like to hear more about that. Who rides with lubricant free BB
bearings?


A number of Pacific NorthWesters who frequently ride through
deep puddles and torrential rainfalls, and don't maintain their
bikes as well as they should for the prevailing conditions.

Besides, no matter how you brace the spindle when pounding
in cotters, the shock reaches the ball or two under the spindle. In


You shouldn't have to pound them in. If you have to pound
them in, they don't fit. Maybe tap them in a little, sure --
but to ~pound~ them in?! Nay.

addition, I saw many cranks secured without more than a 1/2 lb hammer
held under the crank, yet no dents in the spindle resulted.


Of course. The cotters were being smote with a hammer,
not the spindles. I don't think I've ever seen a
dented spindle. I've seen spindles with badly scoured
cones, though. Because the bearings were run dry of lube.

I still have cottered crank spindles lying around that have no sign of
Brinelling although I have a few head sets where both top and bottom
ball bearings as well a roller bearing ones have fretting dimples.


In these rainy Pacific Northwest climes, the lower headset
bearing gets the brunt of the weather, especially when
unprotected by a front fender. The cup serves to guide
splashed-up water into the bearing, washing the lube out.

And it's a sneaky effect, because as long as the upper headset
bearing is fine, everything can appear to be good.


cheers,
Tom

--
Nothing is safe from me.
I'm really at:
tkeats curlicue vcn dot bc dot ca

[email protected] December 21st 08 03:14 PM

Bearing damage?
 
Tom Keats wrote:

smack. Brinelled bearings. specifically unjoyous deployment of
a 4lb hammer when the car's own function can serve the purpose,
and not damage anything.


How come bottom bracket bearing do NOT have this problem when a
hammer is used to drive cotter pins in [1] and out on cranks?


[1] No, tightening is NOT done with the nut with attaching a
cottered crank.


When cotter pins have to be pounded in, there's something horribly
wrong. It usually happens from the bike shop who doesn't quite
have the exact match of what you require, and gives you what they
consider the next closest thing. It's an all too common
occurrence.


Anyway, bearings get ruined by being used dry of grease/lubricant.


I'd like to hear more about that. Who rides with lubricant free BB
bearings?


A number of Pacific Northwesters who frequently ride through deep
puddles and torrential rainfalls, and don't maintain their bikes as
well as they should for the prevailing conditions.


Besides, no matter how you brace the spindle when pounding in
cotters, the shock reaches the ball or two under the spindle. In


You shouldn't have to pound them in. If you have to pound them in,
they don't fit. Maybe tap them in a little, sure -- but to ~pound~
them in?! Nay.


I see you don't work with these. They must be pressed in with
enormous force to give enough preload and insure no "lift-off" from
the small cotter face under hard torque. Those of us who lived
through the steel crank + cotters can recall how they failed with
excess torque if not installed forcefully enough.

They must be driven in with a hammer or a special press. Not only
that, the also needed to be filed to the right wedge angle to match
the other crank in a one side replacement. The off-the-shelf cotter
not being ready to install. The flat taper was only an indication of
where the flat belonged because the threaded end was offset to pass
under the spindle flat. Again, it is a retention nut, not one that
can be used to install the cotter, it having insufficient strength for
that task.

addition, I saw many cranks secured without more than a 1/2 lb
hammer held under the crank, yet no dents in the spindle resulted.


Of course. The cotters were being smote with a hammer, not the
spindles. I don't think I've ever seen a dented spindle. I've seen
spindles with badly scoured cones, though. Because the bearings
were run dry of lube.


Where do you suppose the reaction force went if not through the
spindle to the bearing cups?

I still have cottered crank spindles lying around that have no sign
of Brinelling although I have a few head sets where both top and
bottom ball bearings as well a roller bearing ones have fretting
dimples.


In these rainy Pacific Northwest climes, the lower headset bearing
gets the brunt of the weather, especially when unprotected by a
front fender. The cup serves to guide splashed-up water into the
bearing, washing the lube out.


And it's a sneaky effect, because as long as the upper headset
bearing is fine, everything can appear to be good.


I don't think you analyzed the head bearings correctly. If they were
being bathed in water, they would rust solid when parked. On
inspection, they are not full of water and did not rust. As I
explained, this is a fretting b=problem and that is why the upper head
bearing also shows home position dimples.

Fortunately this problem has been solved with current bearings.

http://www.sheldonbrown.com/brandt/i...-steering.html

Jobst Brandt

jim beam December 21st 08 04:59 PM

Minnesota Winters
 
On Fri, 19 Dec 2008 13:21:17 +0000, Clive George wrote:

"jim beam" wrote in message
...

actually pretty easy to do this - simply loosen the lug nuts a
couple of
turns, then go drive around the block. a couple of hard braking
episodes
will break free the stubbornest of rusted wheels.

God Danged Jim. Thats the only intelligent thing you've ever posted
on this forum.

I did that, and it worked with the front wheel but not the rear wheel.
I had to take additional measures for the rear wheel, including
putting some Liquid Wrench between the rim and hub and engaging in the
telephone book rhumba -- you loosen the lug nuts and then drive the
stuck wheel over a phone book, back and forth. Then you kick the
wheel in strategic locations. That finally worked. Or maybe it was
the swearing that did it.

My 4lb club hammer was bought specifically to remove a wheel from my
car. I'd tried the 1lb one, no joy, no matter how hard I went at it.
4lb one, smack, wheel off.


smack. brinelled bearings. specifically unjoyous deployment of a 4lb
hammer when the car's own function can serve the purpose, and not
damage anything.


And what sort of loads + impacts do the bearings get in normal use?


why don't you work it out? mass. acceleration. point contact area.


What
impacts do they get when you're driving around with loose nuts? You're
raising bogus worries.


no, i'm speaking from experience of failure analysis. bearings that get
hammered get brinelled and subsequently fail. this is not knowledge
exclusive to scientists - technicians with shop experience long enough to
see the consequences will tell you that.


jim beam December 21st 08 05:00 PM

Minnesota Winters
 
On Fri, 19 Dec 2008 10:10:48 -0600, Tim McNamara wrote:

In article ,
"Clive George" wrote:

"jim beam" wrote in message
...

actually pretty easy to do this - simply loosen the lug nuts a
couple of turns, then go drive around the block. a couple of
hard braking episodes will break free the stubbornest of rusted
wheels.

God Danged Jim. Thats the only intelligent thing you've ever
posted on this forum.

I did that, and it worked with the front wheel but not the rear
wheel. I had to take additional measures for the rear wheel,
including putting some Liquid Wrench between the rim and hub and
engaging in the telephone book rhumba -- you loosen the lug nuts and
then drive the stuck wheel over a phone book, back and forth. Then
you kick the wheel in strategic locations. That finally worked. Or
maybe it was the swearing that did it.

My 4lb club hammer was bought specifically to remove a wheel from my
car. I'd tried the 1lb one, no joy, no matter how hard I went at it.
4lb one, smack, wheel off.

smack. brinelled bearings. specifically unjoyous deployment of a
4lb hammer when the car's own function can serve the purpose, and not
damage anything.


And what sort of loads + impacts do the bearings get in normal use?
What impacts do they get when you're driving around with loose nuts?
You're raising bogus worries.


Not our jim!


timmy, why don't you tell us how you managed to calculate how 1800
5000? the mathematical world is on the edge of its seat.

or not. because you're a retard.


jim beam December 21st 08 05:01 PM

Bearing damage?
 
On Sun, 21 Dec 2008 00:24:03 -0600, Tom Sherman wrote:

"jim beam" wrote:
On Wed, 17 Dec 2008 21:52:56 +0000, Clive George wrote:

"Jay Beattie" wrote in message
news:52f52205-62dd-4d66-ac78-

...
On Dec 17, 6:08 am, "
wrote:
On Dec 17, 7:41 am, jim beam wrote:

On Mon, 15 Dec 2008 15:25:07 -0800, Jay Beattie wrote: snip for
clarity
On a somewhat tech note, I went to put on my (car) snow wheels on
Saturday, and my aluminum rims had welded to the iron hubs. Should
have
used my anti-seize! Getting those mo-fos off was a monumental PIA,
but
finally got it done.
actually pretty easy to do this - simply loosen the lug nuts a
couple of
turns, then go drive around the block. a couple of hard braking
episodes
will break free the stubbornest of rusted wheels.
God Danged Jim. Thats the only intelligent thing you've ever posted
on this forum.
I did that, and it worked with the front wheel but not the rear
wheel. I had to take additional measures for the rear wheel,
including putting some Liquid Wrench between the rim and hub and
engaging in the telephone book rhumba -- you loosen the lug nuts and
then drive the stuck wheel over a phone book, back and forth. Then
you kick the wheel in strategic locations. That finally worked. Or
maybe it was the swearing that did it.
My 4lb club hammer was bought specifically to remove a wheel from my
car. I'd tried the 1lb one, no joy, no matter how hard I went at it.
4lb one, smack, wheel off.


smack. brinelled bearings. specifically unjoyous deployment of a 4lb
hammer when the car's own function can serve the purpose, and not
damage anything.


How come bottom bracket bearing do NOT have this problem when a hammer
is used to drive cotter pins in [1] and out on cranks?


ah, nothing like a little jobstian myth to troll the day along! how's it
working for you tom? have you ever done bearing failure analysis?





[1] No, tightening is NOT done with the nut with attaching a cottered
crank.



jim beam December 21st 08 05:06 PM

Bearing damage?
 
On Sun, 21 Dec 2008 07:01:09 +0000, jobst.brandt wrote:

Tom Keats wrote:

smack. Brinelled bearings. specifically unjoyous deployment of a
4lb hammer when the car's own function can serve the purpose, and not
damage anything.


How come bottom bracket bearing do NOT have this problem when a hammer
is used to drive cotter pins in [1] and out on cranks?


[1] No, tightening is NOT done with the nut with attaching a cottered
crank.


When cotter pins have to be pounded in, there's something horribly
wrong. It usually happens from the bike shop who doesn't quite have
the exact match of what you require, and gives you what they consider
the next closest thing. It's an all too common occurrence.


Anyway, bearings get ruined by being used dry of grease/lubricant.


I'd like to hear more about that. Who rides with lubricant free BB
bearings? Besides, no matter how you brace the spindle when pounding in
cotters, the shock reaches the ball or two under the spindle. In
addition, I saw many cranks secured without more than a 1/2 lb hammer
held under the crank, yet no dents in the spindle resulted.


says the great and mighty jobst brandt. not because it doesn't happen,
but because his ego doesn't allow mistake admission and his lack of
learning doesn't allow correction.





I still have cottered crank spindles lying around that have no sign of
Brinelling


of course! jobst brandt looking for evidence of something that would
evidence his gross ignorance is like the fda looking for evidence of mad
cow disease after they've fired all their inspectors!



although I have a few head sets where both top and bottom
ball bearings as well a roller bearing ones have fretting dimples.


no jobst, you have brinelling dimples. don't protect your ignorance like
it's a virtue.




jim beam December 21st 08 05:09 PM

Bearing damage?
 
On Sun, 21 Dec 2008 15:14:30 +0000, jobst.brandt wrote:

snip usual presumptive, mistaken and underinformed crap

jobst, i know it's late in the day for you, but is there /any/ chance
you'll open a book on materials and deformation before you die? it might
stop you looking like a complete ass.



All times are GMT +1. The time now is 01:01 AM.
Home - Home - Home - Home - Home

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
CycleBanter.com