View Single Post
  #17  
Old November 6th 08, 07:03 PM posted to alt.rec.bicycles.recumbent,rec.bicycles.misc,rec.bicycles.soc,alt.mountain-bike
JimmyMac
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 3,754
Default The Dilemma of Tom Sherman

On Nov 4, 3:12*pm, "Edward Dolan" wrote:
"JimmyMac" wrote in message

...
On Nov 1, 5:38 pm, "Edward Dolan" wrote:



"JimmyMac" wrote in message

[...]
If being a member of society is about sharing culture and

hermits do not participate in and/or share in communal culture,
preferring an insular lifestyle of solitude, they consciously reject
the very society that they allegedly are part of, but you just fail to
comprehend what is a very elementary concept.


Wow! Are you sure you ever took any courses in sociology or anthropology.
For God's sakes, if you are even sharing a language you are basically
sharing everything. Hermits share culture just as much if not more than
those who are active socially. If that were not true, how the hell would
we
even be able to communicate with one another.


I understand you quite well and you me. That is because we share a common
culture
Are you sadly incapable of formulating a reasonable, defensible


premise? *OK. .. since you are obviously struggling with what is an
elementary concept, allow me to take one last cut at this. *Sharing
language and/or a common culture are not definitive factors which
determine whether one is a member of society.

Actually, those are the definitive factors. Everything else can be quite
minor and even irrelevant.

A Turk, a Japanese, a


Swahilli, an Eskimo and an Egyptian speak vastly different languages
and are from vastly different cultures, but they are still members of
society ... that is unless they happen to choose the insular,
reclusive, cloistered lifestyle of the hermit.

They are members of a particular society but not of society in general which
does not exist. They are also members of a particular culture, but not of
culture in general which again does not exist.

By choice, a hermit is


NOT a member of society!!! *Enough said in the matter.

You obviously have no conception of the sociological meaning of these terms.
Back to Soc 101 for you!


You obviously have no conception of the sociological meaning of the
term hermit. Back to Soc 101 for you. If everyone in your
mythological concept of society were hermits, how would there possibly
be a society. You have to be one of the most stubbornly illogical
person I have ever encountered ... unwilling to concede a single point
no matter how wrongheaded you happen to be.

Regards,


Ed Dolan the Great - Minnesota
aka
Saint Edward the Great - Order of the Perpetual Sorrows - Minnesota


Ads
 

Home - Home - Home - Home - Home