On Aug 7, 7:21 pm, "Tom Kunich" cyclintom@yahoo. com wrote:
"jim beam" wrote in message

t...

wrote:
Campagnolo had a prototype of it's electronic shifting system. The
problem however is that they have chosen to use the solenoid as the
primary driving mechanism. The same goes for Shimano as well. Mavic's
Mektronic used the d?railleur pulley to drive a worm gear thus saving
weight.

interesting.

The only problem I heard of was the radio frequency interference
problem on rare occasions One complaint had was that the solenoid was
not replaceable.


The Mavic system was handicapped by the mechanism. All it takes is a strong
jolt and the clutches lift and the bike shifts somewhere on it's own.

The other methods probably use stepping motors with leadscrews to give very
precise and reliable position sensitive shifting. The problem is that they
use quite a bit of power.

I'm still trying to figure out what the advantages are to electric shifting.
Anyone got any suggestions? True that if you have electronic shifting you
can shift even if you're a weak kneed shifty eyed moron - say like Kyle,
Howard, Carmine or datakoll. But for anyone with the coordination of a skunk
sprayed squirrel Ergo or STI has no drawbacks aside from those huge lever
bases.