|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Cheltenham cyclists respond to protests over proposals to endtown-centre bike ban
QUOTE:
Cycle campaigners in Cheltenham have replied to concerns by the town’s mayor and a charity that works with the visually impaired that allowing bikes to be ridden through pedestrianised zones in the town centre may put disabled people at risk. Last week, the Macular Disease Society held a demonstration outside the town’s Municipal Offices against the proposals, which have been put forward by Cheltenham Borough Council and Gloucestershire County Council. But John Mallows, chairman of Cheltenham and Tewkesbury Cycling Campaign, told This Is Gloucestershire that the potential problem was being exaggerated and that motorised traffic posed a greater danger to safety. "Very few serious pedestrian casualties arise from cycling,” he explained. “When they do, they are usually on the road and as a result, I suspect, of pedestrians stepping off the kerb without checking. "Without wanting to foster a cycling versus driving spat, pedestrians are at far greater risk on the pavements from cars." Mr Mallow also urged the relevant authorities, in considering whether to lift the ban on cycling in sections of the High Street and the Promenade, to take account of the larger picture in respect of safety, including the fact that the proposed measures would reduce the risk of injury to cyclists who currently have to use the ring road. The newspaper added that Gloucestershire County Council’s Highways department plans to undertake a trial, possibly including new cycle lanes, ahead of any permanent changes being put in place, and that police have said they have problems enforcing the existing ban. http://road.cc/content/news/50139-ch...entre-bike-ban -- Simon Mason |
Ads |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Cheltenham cyclists respond to protests over proposals to endtown-centre bike ban
On 12/01/2012 03:29, Simon Mason wrote:
QUOTE: Cycle campaigners in Cheltenham have replied to concerns by the town’s mayor and a charity that works with the visually impaired that allowing bikes to be ridden through pedestrianised zones in the town centre may put disabled people at risk. Last week, the Macular Disease Society held a demonstration outside the town’s Municipal Offices against the proposals, which have been put forward by Cheltenham Borough Council and Gloucestershire County Council. But John Mallows, chairman of Cheltenham and Tewkesbury Cycling Campaign, told This Is Gloucestershire that the potential problem was being exaggerated and that motorised traffic posed a greater danger to safety. "Very few serious pedestrian casualties arise from cycling,” he explained. “When they do, they are usually on the road and as a result, I suspect, of pedestrians stepping off the kerb without checking. "Without wanting to foster a cycling versus driving spat, pedestrians are at far greater risk on the pavements from cars." He went on: "Even though that last bit was entirely made up out of desperation, who cares about pedestrians at all, especially ones with sight difficulties? Certainly not the Cheltenham and Tewkesbury Cycling Campaign. We are only concerned with our own interests". |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Cheltenham cyclists respond to protests over proposals to endtown-centre bike ban
On Jan 12, 3:29*am, Simon Mason wrote:
"Very few serious pedestrian casualties arise from cycling,” he explained. “When they do, they are usually on the road and as a result, I suspect, of pedestrians stepping off the kerb without checking. These comments from a reader certainly ring true. QUOTE: It's surprisingly high. I can't find the stats offhand but I've seen examples before including vehicles mounting the pavement and vehicles driving too close and striking pedestrians with the wing mirror. It's much higher than you'd think certainly. There was an incident a year or so ago that made the papers for a day or so where a woman had mounted the kerb and run into a group of schoolchildren. Fortunately, no-one seriously injured but can you imagine the outcry if it had been a cyclist running into them?! As it was, it made a couple of column inches and everyone went about their business as usual. -- Simon Mason |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Cheltenham cyclists respond to protests over proposals to end town-centre bike ban
On Thu, 12 Jan 2012 02:29:32 -0800 (PST), Simon Mason
wrote: QUOTE: It's surprisingly high. I can't find the stats offhand That's because there are no "stats". If a motorist is involved in an accident which involves the police it is invariably recorded in Stats19 (effectively the only source of accident data). If a cyclist in a shopping arcade (or anywhere else not classed as a public road) rides down a pedestrian it isn't recorded in Stats 19 even if the victim dies or is seriously injured. A study by the Scottish Executive showed over 40% of cycling accidents occurred in places where they would not be recorded in Stats 19. Pedal cyclists are the type of casualty most under-reported in the Stats 19 returns. DfT's article in Road Casualties Great Britain 2006 compared the "Stats 19" and English Hospitals Episode Statistics (HES) data for pedal cyclist casualties. In England, in the 2005-06 financial year, HES had 7,065 admissions of pedal cyclists, whereas "Stats 19" recorded only 2,092 seriously injured pedal cyclists. The DfT found that almost all the difference was due to HES having 4,268 pedal cyclists who had not been involved in a vehicular collision (e.g. people who just fell off or were thrown from a bicycle which had collided with a pedestrian or some fixed object), whereas "Stats 19" had only 101 such casualties. There was little difference between the number of casualties in HES and "Stats 19" for pedal cyclist accidents which also involved cars, motorcycles, goods vehicles or buses. The differences were proportionately much larger in the case of pedal cyclists who had collided with an object or a pedestrian. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Cheltenham cyclists respond to protests over proposals to endtown-centre bike ban
On Jan 12, 10:29*am, Simon Mason wrote:
On Jan 12, 3:29*am, Simon Mason wrote: "Very few serious pedestrian casualties arise from cycling,” he explained. “When they do, they are usually on the road and as a result, I suspect, of pedestrians stepping off the kerb without checking. These comments from a reader certainly ring true. QUOTE: It's surprisingly high. I can't find the stats offhand but I've seen examples before including vehicles mounting the pavement and vehicles driving too close and striking pedestrians with the wing mirror. It's much higher than you'd think certainly. Updated comment further along the piece. QUOTE: From the CTC: http://www.ctc.org.uk/resources/camp...vement_brf.pdf In London between 2001-05 there were 17 pedestrians killed by motor vehicles on pavements or verges, and not a single cyclist was to blame. -- Simon Mason |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Cheltenham cyclists respond to protests over proposals to end town-centre bike ban
On Thu, 12 Jan 2012 06:36:49 -0800 (PST), Simon Mason
wrote: In London between 2001-05 there were 17 pedestrians killed by motor vehicles on pavements or verges, and not a single cyclist was to blame. How many were killed or injured in pedestrian areas and other places where the accident would go unrecorded in Stats19? Last month for example a colleague of mine assisted a young man who was struck by a cyclist at Euston station and as a result fell and suffered an open fracture to his forearm. The cyclist rode off and the incident will not appear in Stats19. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Cheltenham cyclists respond to protests over proposals to endtown-centre bike ban
Further info.
QUOTE: Figures for 2006-2010 from the Office of National Statistics. Note the "0" for 2009: +------------------------------------------------------------------------ + | Deaths (persons) | |------------------------------------------------------------------------| | Year | (a) Pedestrian hit by pedal cycle | (b) Pedestrian hit by car, pick-up or truck | |------+------------------------------ +----------------------------------| | 2006 | 3 | 233 | |------+------------------------------ +----------------------------------| | 2007 | 6 | 267 | |------+------------------------------ +----------------------------------| | 2008 | 3 | 247 | |------+------------------------------ +----------------------------------| | 2009 | 0 | 141 | |------+------------------------------ +----------------------------------| | 2010 | 2 | 123 | +------------------------------------------------------------------------ + I'm no great statistician but it looks like you're 72 times more likely to be run over and killed on the pavement by a car than a bike. -- Simon Mason |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Cheltenham cyclists respond to protests over proposals to end town-centre bike ban
On Thu, 12 Jan 2012 06:54:03 -0800 (PST), Simon Mason
wrote: I'm no great statistician but it looks like you're 72 times more likely to be run over and killed on the pavement by a car than a bike. That's because you are, as you say, no statistician. If you were you would understand that from incomplete and distorted data you can only get misleading results. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Cheltenham cyclists respond to protests over proposals to endtown-centre bike ban
Further comments.
QUOTE: "pedestrians are at far greater risk on the pavements from cars". Pedestrian casualties in reported1 road accidents: 2008 Road Accident Statistics Factsheet No. 3 – January 2010 Single vehicle accidents with pedestrian casualties Fatal pedestrian casualties Pedal cycle 1 Motorcycle 15 Car 310 Bus or coach 35 LGV 27 HGV 62 Pedestrian location: ....• 10 per cent were on the pavement or verge. ------ Pedestrian casualties in road accidents: 2007 Road Accident Statistics Factsheet No. 3 – November 2008 Single vehicle accidents with pedestrian casualties Fatal pedestrian casualties Pedal cycle 3 Motorcycle 28 Car 336 Bus or coach 42 LGV 40 HGV 66 Pedestrian location: .... • 10 per cent were on the pavement or verge. Source: DfT -- Simon Mason |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Cheltenham cyclists respond to protests over proposals to endtown-centre bike ban
On 12/01/2012 03:29, Simon Mason wrote:
QUOTE: Cycle campaigners in Cheltenham have replied to concerns by the town’s mayor and a charity that works with the visually impaired that allowing bikes to be ridden through pedestrianised zones in the town centre may put disabled people at risk. Last week, the Macular Disease Society held a demonstration outside the town’s Municipal Offices against the proposals, which have been put forward by Cheltenham Borough Council and Gloucestershire County Council. But John Mallows, chairman of Cheltenham and Tewkesbury Cycling Campaign, told This Is Gloucestershire that the potential problem was being exaggerated and that motorised traffic posed a greater danger to safety. "Very few serious pedestrian casualties arise from cycling,” he explained. “When they do, they are usually on the road and as a result, I suspect, of pedestrians stepping off the kerb without checking. So nothing to do with pedestrian zones, "Without wanting to foster a cycling versus driving spat, pedestrians are at far greater risk on the pavements from cars." I wonder how many cars drive in these pedestrian zones. Mr Mallow also urged the relevant authorities, in considering whether to lift the ban on cycling in sections of the High Street and the Promenade, to take account of the larger picture in respect of safety, including the fact that the proposed measures would reduce the risk of injury to cyclists who currently have to use the ring road. Oh I see, bugger the pedestrians. The newspaper added that Gloucestershire County Council’s Highways department plans to undertake a trial, possibly including new cycle lanes, ahead of any permanent changes being put in place, and that police have said they have problems enforcing the existing ban. http://road.cc/content/news/50139-ch...entre-bike-ban -- Simon Mason |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
7000 cyclists to have city centre to themselves. | Simon Mason[_4_] | UK | 3 | May 26th 11 11:31 PM |
Cycling in Cheltenham town centre ban may be lifted | Mrcheerful[_2_] | UK | 4 | December 2nd 10 11:25 AM |
US Sherrif crosses centre-line; kills two; cyclists "collided with deputy's car". | _[_2_] | UK | 6 | March 11th 08 02:51 PM |
Bike in shopping centre | Peter Scandrett | UK | 18 | June 7th 07 05:54 PM |
French Federation Doping Proposals | B. Lafferty | Racing | 2 | November 17th 05 01:47 AM |