|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Commuting Alternative?
I'm curious if anyone has come across a suitable bent for a reasonably
long commute that doesn't cost a fortune? I live just under 40 miles from my work, and sometimes ride my singlespeed upright home. I've lately been considering a fully geared road bike for this ride, leaving my SS for a local bad-weather commuter. That was until I started researching HPV's, where I saw some things that interest me. I've read of people who are not overly athletic covering 40 miles in an hour or just over on some of these sleek HPV's. I average about 15mph on my way home with my SS, and don't see gears bringing me to or past 20. Can I get a 30-40mph aerodynamic 'bent that will be reliable for daily riding without spending 10K? I'd like to pedal my commute when I can, but am not willing to sell my car to make it happen. The Hammacher Schlemmer seems to be the cream of the crop. is there a heavier, slower version for a fraction of the $14K price tag? Any other cheaper bents you'd suggest I check out? TIA, Dan |
Ads |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Commuting Alternative?
|
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Commuting Alternative?
|
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Commuting Alternative?
wrote:
Can I get a 30-40mph aerodynamic 'bent that will be reliable for daily riding without spending 10K? I'd like to pedal my commute when I can, but am not willing to sell my car to make it happen. The Hammacher Schlemmer seems to be the cream of the crop. is there a heavier, slower version for a fraction of the $14K price tag? Any other cheaper bents you'd suggest I check out? Probably the most popular fast velomoble of the moment is the Quest, which you can find out about at http://www.velomobiel.nl/ and it comes in at 40766 Euros without tax. 30783 Euros without tax will get you their "budget" model, the Mango, which seems to have been well received but certainly isn't as fast. Problems... there is, AIUI, a bit of a waiting list. The Leitra (http://www.leitra.dk/) is ~4,500 Euros, won't be as quick as the Dutch ones mentioned above but should move along at a tidy clip all the same. These are all machines that have been in production for some time and have a track record of being usable, practical vehicles that work in windy conditions. Pete. -- Peter Clinch Medical Physics IT Officer Tel 44 1382 660111 ext. 33637 Univ. of Dundee, Ninewells Hospital Fax 44 1382 640177 Dundee DD1 9SY Scotland UK net http://www.dundee.ac.uk/~pjclinch/ |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Commuting Alternative?
Peter Clinch writes:
Probably the most popular fast velomoble of the moment is the Quest, which you can find out about at http://www.velomobiel.nl/ and it comes in at 40766 Euros without tax. 30783 Euros without tax will get you their "budget" model, the Mango, which seems to have been well received but certainly isn't as fast. You seem to have some additional zeros here! The website says 4766 euro and 3782 euro respectively. Still not budget though. Roos |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Commuting Alternative?
Roos Eisma wrote:
Peter Clinch writes: Probably the most popular fast velomoble of the moment is the Quest, which you can find out about at http://www.velomobiel.nl/ and it comes in at 40766 Euros without tax. 30783 Euros without tax will get you their "budget" model, the Mango, which seems to have been well received but certainly isn't as fast. You seem to have some additional zeros here! The website says 4766 euro and 3782 euro respectively. Still not budget though. Oooops, they were commas in the original, wonder what happened there... When it comes to velomobiles, of course, "budget" is a relative term, but these are some way short of the $14K on the one the OP had found. Pete. -- Peter Clinch Medical Physics IT Officer Tel 44 1382 660111 ext. 33637 Univ. of Dundee, Ninewells Hospital Fax 44 1382 640177 Dundee DD1 9SY Scotland UK net http://www.dundee.ac.uk/~pjclinch/ |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Commuting Alternative?
On Jan 23, 4:54 pm, " wrote: Can I get a 30-40mph aerodynamic 'bent that will be reliable for daily riding without spending 10K? No such bike or hpv exists at any price when you are talking about a real world commute by a real world pilot. There are 50+ mile in hour records held by exceptional pilots on a closed track (no hills, no traffic lights ect.) but not in a real wolrd setting. Jim Reilly |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Commuting Alternative?
Thanks to all for the feedback. I'm left with a few questions, no
surprise. First, why would the Leitra be slower than the Quest or Mango? Secondly, would someone really be any faster on the Mango than on a high-end upright? It looks extremely cool if rather heavy. I can envision myself spending a few thousand dollars & discovering that it's actually significantly harder to ride to work than my regular bicycle, perhaps due to the weight on the hills. The F40 looks like an interesting solution as well. I have the same reservations I have about the Mango, however. Also, the F40 is a 'bent with a fairing added. I wonder if a purpose-built velomobile would be more efficient? I've considered power-assisted vehicles, but don't think that's the solution for me. A battery system would be too heavy when under my own power to justify it's assistance, and would not have the juice for my commute. It would also be very expensive with Lithium batteries, and far too heavy to justify its weight with anything else. A gas system would be add a few issues: a) Smell. Parked inside & when running. b) Legality. Suddenly it's a "motorized vehicle" and subject to many laws & regs. c) Personal satisfaction. At that point, why not take the car or motorcycle? I could live with a little electric assist, but a gas motor is too much. It seems I set my expectations too high with my 30-40mph statement. I would be OK with an average speed (including starts, stops & hills) of 20-25mph over my 37.92 mile ride home. My average last ride home was 15.58mph, giving me a 2:25hr ride on my steel singlespeed upright bicycle. I'd need a 19mph average to get me under 2 hours. I don't know if a lightweight geared road bike or a velomobile would accomplish this or not. I also expect I'll be a little faster month to month, at least until I get into peak shape. I'd really like to speak with an upright rider who has logged some miles in a velomobile to see how it compared. I'd hate to spend all that money on one to find that I should have bought a road bike. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Commuting Alternative?
Based on my albeit limited experience, unless you commute in an
especially hilly area, you should average a higher speed on a recumbent, all things being equal (fitness, quality of bike, etc). I was able to sustain average speeds of well over 25 mph on an Easy Racer Gold Rush along the Erie Canal trail. In average physical shape at the time. I could have hit upwards of 30 mph w/ additional effort. YMMV On Jan 24, 8:14 am, Peter Clinch wrote: wrote: First, why would the Leitra be slower than the Quest or Mango?Not as aerodynamic. Secondly, would someone really be any faster on the Mango than on a high-end upright? Yes, because of the aerodynamics. It looks extremely cool if rather heavy.Quite so, but as high speeds weight is less important than air resistance. With "normal" race bikes the UCI specifically ban aerodynamic aids, but using fairings the IHPVA speed records are about 30% better than the UCI "official" ones. I can envision myself spending a few thousand dollars & discovering that it's actually significantly harder to ride to work than my regular bicycle, perhaps due to the weight on the hills.Once your speed drops under a critical value then weight will matter more than the aerodynamics, but it's worth noting that the real-roads UK "End to End" ride (over 800 miles with /lots/ of hills) has the record held by a faired trike, with the rider taking his own upright racer based record. Also, what goes up, must come down, and then your aerodynamics wins out again. The F40 looks like an interesting solution as well. I have the same reservations I have about the Mango, however. Also, the F40 is a 'bent with a fairing added. I wonder if a purpose-built velomobile would be more efficient?What /may/ be the case is it's a lot more stable in side winds. Talk to people with real experience of them for that though. It seems I set my expectations too high with my 30-40mph statement. I would be OK with an average speed (including starts, stops & hills) of 20-25mph over my 37.92 mile ride home. My average last ride home was 15.58mph, giving me a 2:25hr ride on my steel singlespeed upright bicycle. I'd need a 19mph average to get me under 2 hours. I don't know if a lightweight geared road bike or a velomobile would accomplish this or not. I also expect I'll be a little faster month to month, at least until I get into peak shape.If the roads aren't particularly exceptionally poorly suited, a fully faired machine should give you a more reliable overall figure (i.e., with less difference between still and headwind days). My guess is the average should be better as long as you're keeping effort high, because aerodynamics takes up the lion's share of the effort any time you're above about 15 mph. Pete. -- Peter Clinch Medical Physics IT Officer Tel 44 1382 660111 ext. 33637 Univ. of Dundee, Ninewells Hospital Fax 44 1382 640177 Dundee DD1 9SY Scotland UK net http://www.dundee.ac.uk/~pjclinch/ |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Alternative Inner Tubes? | milk | Unicycling | 1 | September 23rd 06 09:36 PM |
An alternative to the hub generator? | PiledHigher | Australia | 4 | July 24th 06 12:44 AM |
Alternative politics | [email protected] | Recumbent Biking | 0 | May 13th 05 05:17 PM |
RR Bloomsday Alternative | small change | Mountain Biking | 1 | May 2nd 05 11:28 PM |