A Cycling & bikes forum. CycleBanter.com

Go Back   Home » CycleBanter.com forum » rec.bicycles » Racing
Site Map Home Register Authors List Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read Web Partners

Could Lance break the "athlete's hour" record?



 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old July 22nd 03, 10:00 PM
Boyd Speerschneider
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default Could Lance break the "athlete's hour" record?

karhu wrote in news:Xns93C0E70A8400nospamhotmailcom@
195.54.106.227:

What do you think? I think he should go for it to prove that he is the
greatest rider of all time. It would be like going one-on-one with Eddy
Merckx... (I know that Boardman holds the record (49.441 km), but that is
just 10 meters more than Merckx). If Lance could do 50+ then the issue of
who´s the greatest rider would be settled once and for all.


Hardly.

When Lance:

1) wins all three jerseys at the TDF
2) wins a bunch of classics
3) wins like 50% of the races he enters
4) races from January to October
3) holds the hour record

Then he will be the greatest of all time.

- Boyd S.
holding breath
Ads
  #2  
Old July 22nd 03, 10:02 PM
Gary
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default Could Lance break the "athlete's hour" record?

Is that REALLY the test? How much climbing is involved in the one-hour
record?

karhu wrote:

What do you think? I think he should go for it to prove that he is the
greatest rider of all time. It would be like going one-on-one with Eddy
Merckx... (I know that Boardman holds the record (49.441 km), but that is
just 10 meters more than Merckx). If Lance could do 50+ then the issue of
who´s the greatest rider would be settled once and for all.



  #3  
Old July 22nd 03, 10:21 PM
Jbenkert111
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default Could Lance break the "athlete's hour" record?

Impossible, as in all sports records and best of "all time" nominations,
comparisons cannot be made with any degree of accuracy. Different era,
different caliber riders. For instance, Merckx, won all those races against
riders that were also doing all those races and were probably just as tired as
he, and also, the talent pool is much larger and stronger these days. You can
argue, who was most dominant in their era, which is still meaningless. The
only thing we can say for sure, is that they are the best of their time.


What do you think? I think he should go for it to prove that he is the
greatest rider of all time. It would be like going one-on-one with Eddy
Merckx... (I know that Boardman holds the record (49.441 km), but that is
just 10 meters more than Merckx). If Lance could do 50+ then the issue of
who´s the greatest rider would be settled once and for all.









  #4  
Old July 22nd 03, 10:28 PM
Mark & Steven Bornfeld DDS
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default Could Lance break the "athlete's hour" record?



Jbenkert111 wrote:

Impossible, as in all sports records and best of "all time" nominations,
comparisons cannot be made with any degree of accuracy.


True, still...

Different era,
different caliber riders. For instance, Merckx, won all those races against
riders that were also doing all those races and were probably just as tired as
he, and also, the talent pool is much larger and stronger these days.


You think?

You can
argue, who was most dominant in their era, which is still meaningless. The
only thing we can say for sure, is that they are the best of their time.


I'll bet if you asked Lance, he'd have no trouble saying Merckx was the
greatest. This business of Merckx not having any worthy competition is the old
canard that hounded him all his career, and all the years after. Gimondi, Aldig,
de Vlaeminck, Pollentier, van Looy, Anquetil--yeah, some of these guys were past
their prime, some not. I still think he was given a bum rap. He is the greatest
because he HAD to win every single race he entered.

Steve




What do you think? I think he should go for it to prove that he is the
greatest rider of all time. It would be like going one-on-one with Eddy
Merckx... (I know that Boardman holds the record (49.441 km), but that is
just 10 meters more than Merckx). If Lance could do 50+ then the issue of
who´s the greatest rider would be settled once and for all.








--
Mark & Steven Bornfeld DDS
Brooklyn, NY
718-258-5001
http://www.dentaltwins.com


  #5  
Old July 22nd 03, 10:35 PM
Andy Coggan
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default Could Lance break the "athlete's hour" record?

"karhu" wrote in message
7...
What do you think? I think he should go for it to prove that he is the
greatest rider of all time. It would be like going one-on-one with Eddy
Merckx... (I know that Boardman holds the record (49.441 km), but that is
just 10 meters more than Merckx).


10 m is 10 m...so it would be like going one-on-one with Boardman.

If Lance could do 50+ then the issue of
who´s the greatest rider would be settled once and for all.


If Boardman had raced under the new rules with the form he had in setting
his ultimate record, the distance would be out around 51.5-52 km...

Andy Coggan


  #6  
Old July 22nd 03, 10:54 PM
Davide Tosi
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default Could Lance break the "athlete's hour" record?

Gerrit Stolte wrote:

On Tue, 22 Jul 2003 17:28:47 -0400, Mark & Steven Bornfeld DDS
wrote:



Jbenkert111 wrote:

Impossible, as in all sports records and best of "all time" nominations,
comparisons cannot be made with any degree of accuracy.


True, still...

Different era,
different caliber riders. For instance, Merckx, won all those races against
riders that were also doing all those races and were probably just as tired as
he, and also, the talent pool is much larger and stronger these days.


You think?


Factual evidence. It has become a professional sport, with all the
consequences.


In Europe cycling has always been a professinal sport, that in the past was
even bigger than it is now. In the 50s cycling used to attract the kind of
crowds that only soccer attracts now. People like Coppi, Bobet, Van
Steenbergen, Kubler were by far the most popular sportsmen of their own
countries.
In some aspects - ie the capacity of building hugely acclaimed legends -
cycling is less professional than it once was.

  #7  
Old July 22nd 03, 10:57 PM
Gerrit Stolte
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default Could Lance break the "athlete's hour" record?

On Tue, 22 Jul 2003 17:28:47 -0400, Mark & Steven Bornfeld DDS
wrote:



Jbenkert111 wrote:

Impossible, as in all sports records and best of "all time" nominations,
comparisons cannot be made with any degree of accuracy.


True, still...

Different era,
different caliber riders. For instance, Merckx, won all those races against
riders that were also doing all those races and were probably just as tired as
he, and also, the talent pool is much larger and stronger these days.


You think?


Factual evidence. It has become a professional sport, with all the
consequences. Or do you believe that any of the, say, mid-50s basketball
teams would have have even a *slight* chance of losing with less than 20
points to the Spurs, Kings, Lakers, Nets, Mavs? Or, to put it bluntly,
the Lakers of the 40s would go out with a 2-80 record out of the regular
season, if two opponents wouldn't show up. Too slow, too small ...

Gerrit

  #8  
Old July 22nd 03, 11:08 PM
one of the six billion
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default Could Lance break the "athlete's hour" record?


"karhu" wrote in message
7...
What do you think? I think he should go for it to prove that he is the
greatest rider of all time. It would be like going one-on-one with Eddy
Merckx... (I know that Boardman holds the record (49.441 km), but that is
just 10 meters more than Merckx). If Lance could do 50+ then the issue of
who´s the greatest rider would be settled once and for all.


The "greatest" racer is not the "fastest" racer. There are so many
different aspects to road racing you could never comparatively quantify who
is the greatest. If you chose one dimension such as speed, then what about
time. Who decides that the greatest is one who can travel the most
distance over an hour. What about ultra endurance athletes that travel
3000 miles in 9 days, what about sprinters and track athletes that hit
speeds close to 50 mph? The Tour throws out endurance, individual speed,
hill climbing, team speed and tactics and individual rivalries in ways that
can't be quantified. If you're going to be number oriented you miss out on
the amazing phenomena that the Tour is.





  #9  
Old July 23rd 03, 02:49 AM
Antonio Sanchez
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default Could Lance break the "athlete's hour" record?



For instance, Merckx, won all those races against
riders that were also doing all those races and were probably just as

tired as
he, and also, the talent pool is much larger and stronger these days. You

can
argue, who was most dominant in their era, which is still meaningless.

The
only thing we can say for sure, is that they are the best of their time.


Merckx won a record of 33 BIG Classics riding against other cyclists who
dedicated only for the Classics and not "as tired as Merckx", and equaled
the records in the Giro and Tour (with 5 wins in both) against very hard
opposition from stage race specialists, often with coalition of riders that
worked to see his defeat. He also won the Vuelta in 1973, and 3 times the
World Championship. His list of professional road wins is incredibly wide
(525 to be more exact). But he also contested the Six day races in the
winter against the greatest track specialists of the time, winning them as
well.

When he was fighting for his sixth Tour and wearing the maillot jaune, he
has been hitten in the stomach by a French fanatic and fell while climbing
the Puy-de-Dome, requiring some medication that affected his performance in
the following stages, allowing French climber Bernard Thevenet to win the
Tour by 2'47". He also had a crash with one week to go and BROKE his
jawbone, taking only liquids or mashed food with great pain during the last
week of the race. Everybody told him to quit, but he said he was going to
continue to give Thevenet the satisfaction to see him in the second place of
the podium.
Take only this sample (there are many more) to learn why Eddy Merckx was the
greatest rider of all time.





  #10  
Old July 23rd 03, 05:39 AM
warren
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default Could Lance break the "athlete's hour" record?

In article , Steven Bornfeld
wrote:

I agree with Davide. While there is some truth to what you say, that
cycling has become more international, most of the improvement in (for
instance) average speed in pro races has far more to do with improved
roads, riding conditions and equipment than it has to do with gene pool
dynamics.



No credit for better training methods?

-WG
 




Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
thoughts from chris carmichael on lance deing dehydrated dwjones Racing 25 July 24th 03 04:33 AM
Lance won't win #5 this year dwjones Racing 17 July 19th 03 05:44 PM
In defence of the Lance era Bret Wade Racing 5 July 15th 03 11:11 PM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:54 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 CycleBanter.com.
The comments are property of their posters.