|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
New Bike Recommendations Needed
I'm interested in getting some opinions/recommendations on a new lower-end
road bike to replace my two-year-old Trek 7300 Hybrid. Overall I've been pleased with the 7300, but I find that I really miss the drop handlebars. My riding is mostly fitness and recreational and occurs mostly on paved roads. However, I do have a need for a bike which can handle packed dirt roads without suffering severe tire/wheel/frame damage. Typically I only ride 50+ miles a week over flat to moderately hilly terrain. I'm also not inclined to spend a fortune on a new bike. Ideally I would like to spend less than $1000 and probably no more than $1500. I've been looking at some of the new 'comfort' road bikes produced by Trek and Specialized. In particular the Trek 1000C/1200C and the Specialized Sequoia series. I've also read good things about the Bianchi Volpe. They all seem to be in the right price range and seem to be closer to a hybrid bike than a road bike. Are there other bikes by other manufacturers which are similar? One question I have about all of these bikes is how wide of a tire I could put on them. They seem to come with 700x28C tires by default. My hybrid has 700x38C tires. Could I put 700x38c tires on any of these bikes? I'm also not sure how to evaluate the different equipment groups which come on these bikes. For example, the Trek 1000C uses Shimano Sora components and sells for around $600. The low-end Specialized Sequoia uses Sora components but sells in the $800 range. The 1200C and the Volpe, which are closer to the $900 range, use Shimano Tiagra. The mid-level Specialized Sequoia uses Shimano New 105 components and sells for $1200. What are the major differences between these components and would a casual rider such as myself really benefit from spending hundreds of dollars more for better components? Obviously one thing to do is try the bikes out to see which feels the best, but I'd still like opinions about what people like and don't like about the various components. I'm interested in any opinions that people may have on bikes which may meet my requirements. Thanks. -- James Howe |
Ads |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
New Bike Recommendations Needed
|
#3
|
|||
|
|||
New Bike Recommendations Needed
x-no-archive:yes
I am a big fan of Bianchi. Their bikes ride so smooth and they have a lot of value for the money. Pat in TX |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
New Bike Recommendations Needed
x-no-archive:yes
: I am a big fan of Bianchi. Their bikes ride so smooth and they have a lot of value for the money. How do you mean that? Is this the smoothness of the paint or the transitions of the tube joints?... or are you implying that Bianchi frames are soft and flex more than tires that usually absorb road shock of bicycles (if they aren't FS MTB's). I feel that old black magic coming on... "steel frames get soft with time etc". Jobst Brandt I just meant that when I tried out the Bianchi Eros and Bianchi Veloce, they felt smoother to ride than the Klein, LeMond, and Cannondale bikes that I also tried out. Of course, my old bike was a 1984 Schwinn, so practically anything would have been quicker and more responsive....I think Bianchi has good quality frames, the angles in their frames feel good when I ride them, and they were reasonably light for the price. Are you always so acerbic? Pat in TX |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
New Bike Recommendations Needed
James Howe wrote in message ...
road bike to replace my two-year-old Trek 7300 Hybrid. Overall I've been pleased with the 7300, but I find that I really miss the drop handlebars. You could add Newk extensions (curve down like dropped bars, don't relocate the controls - OK if you spend most of the time "on the tops"). Or switch the stem, bars, and controls, keeping in mind that most V-brakes need an adapter to work with STI levers (different cable pull). Some manufacturers sell a "touring bike" which is just their hybrid with dropped bars, STI levers, narrower tires, and different crankset (30-42-52 instead of 22-32-42). These are cheaper options. ymmv tire I could put on them. They seem to come with 700x28C tires by default. Most "road" bikes lack clearance for wider tires, fenders, racks, panniers, etc. You might look for "touring" bikes. Or CycloCross bikes, but these seem to have higher bottom brackets, and cost more than a tourer. Could I put 700x38c tires on any of these bikes? www.sheldonbrown.com has a table of tire widths for rim widths. The other limiting factor is clearance - wide tires may rub the frame or brake arches. You can always deflate the tire to squeeze it past the brake pads, then re-inflate it. Many touring bikes use cantilever or v-brakes (see sheldonbrown's glossary) , which are closer to the $900 range, use Shimano Tiagra. The mid-level See www.chainreactionbicycles.com article on test riding a bike. You really can't judge a group (specifically shifters) without riding it. I got severe hand / arm pain from RSX STI levers, but have no such grief from 105's. Tiagra looks like a nice 9-speed group, Sora limits your upgrade options (8 speed) and has "mouse-ears" rather than a second lever inside the main brake-shift lever. Some people prefer barcons, as used on the Trek 520. ymmv. Specialized Sequoia uses Shimano New 105 components and sells for $1200. My 105's have two cnetral positions for the FD, to allow some trimming when on the middle chainring. RSX didn't have that, don't know whether Taigra does. You could read the SHimano blurbs for other differences, which may contribute to durability, or function. You may find Campagnolo ERGO at that price level as well (e.g. the Marinoni Turismo with Campy Veloce costs C$1760, which is less than your U$1500 limit). Some touring bikes mix road and ATB compnents, e.g. 105 ST levers, LX hubs and wide-range cassette, LX derailleur to cope with the ATB cassette, etc. hth |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
New Bike Recommendations Needed
James Howe wrote in message ...
I'm interested in getting some opinions/recommendations on a new lower-end road bike to replace my two-year-old Trek 7300 Hybrid. Overall I've been pleased with the 7300, but I find that I really miss the drop handlebars. My riding is mostly fitness and recreational and occurs mostly on paved roads. However, I do have a need for a bike which can handle packed dirt roads without suffering severe tire/wheel/frame damage. Typically I only ride 50+ miles a week over flat to moderately hilly terrain. I'm also not inclined to spend a fortune on a new bike. Ideally I would like to spend less than $1000 and probably no more than $1500. Fuji Touring, MSRP is $840 Bianchi Volpe MSRP is $850 These would appear to fit your requirements pretty well. Look for a Cro-Moly framed bicycle, not an aluminum framed bicycle. As to the widest tire, no problem with 38mm on the Fuji, see the chart at: "http://sheldonbrown.com/tire-sizing.html" The Fuji comes with Ritchey Tom Slick, 700 x 30C and Alex X-2100 rims. The rims have an inside diameter of 18.8mm, so you could technically go up to 44mm wide tires, and in fact you can find bikes with 38mm tires and these rims. The Volpe has Mavic T-224 rims. Mavic doesn't have the width on their web site, but they do list tire pressure for 28mm-37mm tires, so probably 38mm would be okay. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
New Bike Recommendations Needed
x-no-archive:yes
.. James Howe These would appear to fit your requirements pretty well. Look for a Cro-Moly framed bicycle, not an aluminum framed bicycle. duck! run for cover! Pat in TX |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
New Bike Recommendations Needed
"Pat" wrote in message ... x-no-archive:yes . James Howe These would appear to fit your requirements pretty well. Look for a Cro-Moly framed bicycle, not an aluminum framed bicycle. The original poster stated that he wanted a bike that was not strictly for on-road riding and that could stand up to some abuse. I don't think anyone would argue that aluminum is better than steel in terms of meeting these requirements. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Needing Female Bicycle Recommendations... | Chad Thompson | General | 6 | August 26th 03 07:20 AM |
Bike for big AND tall person | Peter Cole | General | 20 | August 13th 03 01:38 PM |
Bike recommendations | thomas_delaney | General | 1 | July 29th 03 04:27 AM |
Couple questions about bike tires | Dan Musicant | General | 19 | July 24th 03 09:56 PM |
Couple questions about bike tires | Dan Musicant | General | 3 | July 18th 03 08:18 PM |