|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Help on choosing new bike
There are so many different bicycle options these days that I'm
completely lost. But before I decide on specific models I need to figure out what type of bike I need. I've cycled when I was in my youth on a road bike (mostly on dirt trails!) and recently with a Full MTB (mostly on asphalt!!). I know, I made poor choices but I misjudged what kind of riding I was going to do. This time around I know exactly how I'm going to use it so hopefully I'll be better equiped. I ride mostly to keep fit and because I enjoy it a lot. And by keeping fit it doesn't have anything to do with loosing weight, just a good heart rate. I train daily on city trails (flat asphalt) and there is a weekend mountain climb (asphalt) that I really like. It's about 3km long with an average climb rate of 8%. I'm addicted to mountain climbs and wish I could do it more often. There are some monthly group day trips I participate which can stretch to 100Km but always on asphalt and relaxed pace. With all that in mind I was considering a hardtail MTB but I don't know if I really need the front suspension (and additional weight). What kind of configuration do you guys think is best suited for me? I hear a lot of talk about "frame geometry", how important is that for me and how do I make the right choice? If you can suggest some models that would be sweet. Money is not an issue but I'm no pro so high-end models are out. tks! |
Ads |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Help on choosing new bike
On May 25, 10:30 am, Shark wrote:
With all that in mind I was considering a hardtail MTB but I don't know if I really need the front suspension (and additional weight). What kind of configuration do you guys think is best suited for me? An all purpose road bike with drop bars at saddle height and tires around 30mm is comfy all day, fast, and can go anywhere from asphalt to the occasional dirt road. Such bikes come under the stealth names such as "cyclocross" bikes which sometimes just need some pavement specific tires, or "touring" bikes. This is the kind of bike that people rode for years and years until the industry decided otherwise. However--if you really don't get along with drop bars--a fully rigid "hybrid" bike is a good option, and there are plenty that are very decent quality and quite affordable. You don't need a suspension on the road, you don't need knobby tires, and you don't need overly skinny tires. The only scenario where a hardtail mtb might be a good option, and that's if it's retrofitted with street tires, is if you're a heavier person, as they're quite sturdy, otherwise, steer clear. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Help on choosing new bike
Shark wrote:
There are so many different bicycle options these days that I'm completely lost. But before I decide on specific models I need to figure out what type of bike I need. I've cycled when I was in my youth on a road bike (mostly on dirt trails!) and recently with a Full MTB (mostly on asphalt!!). I know, I made poor choices but I misjudged what kind of riding I was going to do. This time around I know exactly how I'm going to use it so hopefully I'll be better equiped. I ride mostly to keep fit and because I enjoy it a lot. And by keeping fit it doesn't have anything to do with loosing weight, just a good heart rate. I train daily on city trails (flat asphalt) and there is a weekend mountain climb (asphalt) that I really like. It's about 3km long with an average climb rate of 8%. I'm addicted to mountain climbs and wish I could do it more often. There are some monthly group day trips I participate which can stretch to 100Km but always on asphalt and relaxed pace. With all that in mind I was considering a hardtail MTB but I don't know if I really need the front suspension (and additional weight). What kind of configuration do you guys think is best suited for me? I hear a lot of talk about "frame geometry", how important is that for me and how do I make the right choice? If you can suggest some models that would be sweet. Money is not an issue but I'm no pro so high-end models are out. Sounds to me like maybe you need TWO bikes, one for on the road and one for off. Bill __o |Weaning our nation from fossil fuels should be understood as _`\(,_ |the most patriotic policy to which we can commit ourselves. (_)/ (_) | -Robert Redford |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Help on choosing new bike
wrote in message
... Shark wrote: Sounds to me like maybe you need TWO bikes, one for on the road and one for off. Sounds to me like he need a Specialized Tricross sport http://www.specialized.com/bc/SBCBkModel.jsp?spid=32209 I used to have only a hard tail mtb (Marin nail trail) but realized that as 95% of my riding was on road, forest trail or river towpath that was not the best option. I opted for the Tricross that covers everything from road to trail/towpath and now use the mtb only for rough off road or mud pk |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Help on choosing new bike
"Shark" wrote in message ... There are so many different bicycle options these days that I'm completely lost. But before I decide on specific models I need to figure out what type of bike I need. I've cycled when I was in my youth on a road bike (mostly on dirt trails!) and recently with a Full MTB (mostly on asphalt!!). I know, I made poor choices but I misjudged what kind of riding I was going to do. This time around I know exactly how I'm going to use it so hopefully I'll be better equiped. I ride mostly to keep fit and because I enjoy it a lot. And by keeping fit it doesn't have anything to do with loosing weight, just a good heart rate. I train daily on city trails (flat asphalt) and there is a weekend mountain climb (asphalt) that I really like. It's about 3km long with an average climb rate of 8%. I'm addicted to mountain climbs and wish I could do it more often. There are some monthly group day trips I participate which can stretch to 100Km but always on asphalt and relaxed pace. With all that in mind I was considering a hardtail MTB but I don't know if I really need the front suspension (and additional weight). What kind of configuration do you guys think is best suited for me? I hear a lot of talk about "frame geometry", how important is that for me and how do I make the right choice? If you can suggest some models that would be sweet. Money is not an issue but I'm no pro so high-end models are out. tks! Landotter is heading in the same direction I would given your riding preference. Rather than, as someone else suggested, getting two bikes, get two sets of tires: one more roadable and the other with a deeper tread for off road. Cyclocross is a good way to go. Another option, one that I recently went with, is a 29er. These are more mountain bike oriented frames than a cyclocross, hence a more upright position, than cyclocross. The rim is a 700c, but the tires have a very high sidewall, thus the 29 inch wheel size. I can't speak for all the rims on all inchers, but wine will also accommodate 35mm width on a standard 700c. I've not gone that skinny, but I do have two sets of tires: one really aggressive off road and one about a ¼ inch narrower with a raised center for more road / hard pack / rails-to-trails type riding. They fly on the pavement! Just the forks have suspension and this is the first bike I've owned with any suspension. I am now spoiled. Unless it is a pure road trip, and even then it had better be very well maintained pavement, I love the way the front shock makes the ride much more enjoyable. YMMV Whatever you pick, get a good bike and enjoy the ride! |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Help on choosing new bike
cyclocross bikes are the best for all around. 29'ers are just hype
trying to get p;eople to buy a new bike. On May 25, 4:44*pm, "emanon" wrote: "Shark" wrote in message ... There are so many different bicycle options these days that I'm completely lost. But before I decide on specific models I need to figure out what type of bike I need. I've cycled when I was in my youth on a road bike (mostly on dirt trails!) and recently with a Full MTB (mostly on asphalt!!). I know, I made poor choices but I misjudged what kind of riding I was going to do. This time around I know exactly how I'm going to use it so hopefully I'll be better equiped. I ride mostly to keep fit and because I enjoy it a lot. And by keeping fit it doesn't have anything to do with loosing weight, just a good heart rate. I train daily on city trails (flat asphalt) and there is a weekend mountain climb (asphalt) that I really like. It's about 3km long with an average climb rate of 8%. I'm addicted to mountain climbs and wish I could do it more often. There are some monthly group day trips I participate which can stretch to 100Km but always on asphalt and relaxed pace. With all that in mind I was considering a hardtail MTB but I don't know if I really need the front suspension (and additional weight). What kind of configuration do you guys think is best suited for me? I hear a lot of talk about "frame geometry", how important is that for me and how do I make the right choice? If you can suggest some models that would be sweet. Money is not an issue but I'm no pro so high-end models are out. tks! Landotter is heading in the same direction I would given your riding preference. Rather than, as someone else suggested, getting two bikes, get two sets of tires: one more roadable and the other with a deeper tread for off road. Cyclocross is a good way to go. Another option, one that I recently went with, is a 29er. These are more mountain bike oriented frames than a cyclocross, hence a more upright position, than cyclocross. The rim is a 700c, but the tires have a very high sidewall, thus the 29 inch wheel size.. I can't speak for all the rims on all inchers, but wine will also accommodate 35mm width on a standard 700c. I've not gone that skinny, but I do have two sets of tires: one really aggressive off road and one about a ¼ inch narrower with a raised center for more road / hard pack / rails-to-trails type riding. They fly on the pavement! Just the forks have suspension and this is the first bike I've owned with any suspension. I am now spoiled. Unless it is a pure road trip, and even then it had better be very well maintained pavement, I love the way the front shock makes the ride much more enjoyable. YMMV Whatever you pick, get a good bike and enjoy the ride!- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Help on choosing new bike
On May 25, 9:51 pm, wrote:
cyclocross bikes are the best for all around. Not at all--they are designed for cross. Touring bikes are the best bikes for all round. Cross bikes with racks and panniers and size 44s can mean heel strike, and even fender flap/toe interference. They get pushed out the door--especially at my local LBS, as they're "edgier" than touring bikes--but sold to folks for the same uses. Shame that to get them out the door with all that "edge", they're getting a steeper geometry and short stays--while fine for unloaded riding, and indeed great for cross, they're really not going to be all that fun for loaded touring, despite the fact that you can mount up racks. Certainly, cross bikes are a better option, especially mounted up with some nice 28-35mm skinwall nominal slicks compared to the race bikes people are using for crouching over simply to get exercise. FWIW, my LBS has never had a normal touring bike on the sales floor. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Help on choosing new bike
On May 25, 10:30 am, Shark wrote:
I ride mostly to keep fit and because I enjoy it a lot. And by keeping fit it doesn't have anything to do with loosing weight... Sound to me like a bike that can ride the path and perhaps do useful errands might be nice. That's not an easy bike to buy... the bike shops don't sell good riding bikes that can also haul stuff. (they tend to sell bikes with carbon accessories and disk brakes and 32 gears) But hauling groceries, or doing weekend chores, is a great way to make your bicycling habit more than just exercise. You can get great benefit by simply riding to and from the grocery store several times a week. (and still do the daily path stuff) I'm not suggesting a cargo/work bike. I'm thinking of a 22-25 pound machine that will go fast, go far, ride a lot of surfaces... and carry stuff. Rivendell's Atlantis is an example (but expensive). You might go over to kogswell.com and look at the pictures. He's got a really good concept. It's better than your typical touring rig, since the handling is livelier. In any case... the best way to get a good bike (not necessarily a big $ $$ bike) is to select a frame and have your local mechanic build it up. That way you get the right wheels (very important) and right gearing for your geography and fitness level. A used high-end road frame (from the days of lugged, butted steel) is often the best solution... |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Help on choosing new bike
On May 26, 10:08*am, Will wrote:
In any case... the best way to get a good bike (not necessarily a big $ $$ bike) is to select a frame and have your local mechanic build it up. That way you get the right wheels (very important) and right gearing for your geography and fitness level. It's extremely rare for this to be economically smart. For example, try building out a Surly LHT frame specced the same as their complete bike for $600 on top of the frame. Can't be done. Usually smarter to buy a complete bike and sub parts as necessary. Machine built wheels are easily tuned. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Help on choosing new bike
On May 26, 10:25 am, landotter wrote:
It's extremely rare for this to be economically smart. A question... do you have a stand and tools? And if so, why? If not, your money argument makes perfect sense and I agree with it. |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Choosing a new bike ... | iPleb | UK | 18 | August 16th 07 06:30 PM |
Choosing a bike... | Eric C.[_2_] | Techniques | 2 | June 10th 07 08:57 AM |
Help choosing correct bike | Mike | UK | 12 | January 16th 07 11:43 PM |
Choosing new mountain bike. | vjump1 | Mountain Biking | 15 | October 10th 04 01:40 AM |
Where to start choosing first bike? | ITMA | Mountain Biking | 1 | April 26th 04 10:56 PM |