fit

I've seen some fit stories in some messages, and just thought I'd
throw this one out there, too.

I'm 5'2.5". I have short legs, short arms, and yup, a short torso. I
would really prefer NOT to have 650c wheels/tires if I can avoid it.
I'm putting my old Klein into retirement as a getting to work
bike/travel bike (it is an old aluminum frame bike that was new in
like '98). I think my Klein is like a 51cm...but I can't remember
exactly.

Mostly i like to just ride, and occasionally i like to ride long
(trained for an ironman last year). I certainly would like an upgrade
and am thinking that I'd like something a little softer to ride on,
i.e., not aluminum. I'm not a super serious, competitive rider, but I
do like to be comfortable, and appreciate a nice bike. I'll probably
be doing some longer rides--50+ miles, 2-3x/wk but probably not racing
(maybe an occasional tri).

I'm a little averse to Bianchi...not the company or what they do, just
that i've tested these bikes a bunch of times and just don't seem to
work for me--not comfy--ironically, I think the top tube is too short.
I'd be up for a Trek, I suppose...just about other choices out there.

So, here is the question:
I know a bunch of folks out there have so much more experience than I
do. What manufacturers would you suggest for frames (am willing to
build my own)that would be suitable for my needs???

Thanks in advance!
Deb

Deb wrote:

I'm 5'2.5". I have short legs, short arms, and yup, a short torso. I
would really prefer NOT to have 650c wheels/tires if I can avoid it.

I understand your reluctance to 650c wheels, but that's about the only way
to get a "normal" geometry in a small frame. Compact frames have some
advantages, but you still get a weird geometry and/or toe overlap.

I'm putting my old Klein into retirement as a getting to work
bike/travel bike (it is an old aluminum frame bike that was new in
like '98). I think my Klein is like a 51cm...but I can't remember
exactly.

"Frame size" (i.e., seat tube length) isn't the most critical thing in a
fit. Concentrate more on top tube length, and the overall geometry
including BB height.

I'm a little averse to Bianchi...not the company or what they do, just
that i've tested these bikes a bunch of times and just don't seem to
work for me--not comfy--ironically, I think the top tube is too short.
I'd be up for a Trek, I suppose...just about other choices out there.

Unless the bike is set up properly for you, a test ride can be misleading.
What don't you like about your current bike? I don't really buy the
"aluminum is harsh" theory. Is there a particular problem with fit or
handling?

Art Harris