|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Does drafting help the guy in frount?
Ok first my understanding of the way drag (air resistence) works. There is two main sources of drag, the first one is from pushing the air away infrount of you, and the second source of drag is from the air rushing in to fill the partial vacume behind you. This is why stuff designed for areodynamics normally has the classic teardrop shape, with the tail out the end to allow the air to rush back in smoothly. Wouldn't having a bike behind you transfur the second sort of drag to him freeing you from this? -- Please excuse my spelling as I suffer from agraphia. See http://dformosa.zeta.org.au/~dformosa/Spelling.html to find out more. Free the Memes. |
Ads |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Does drafting help the guy in frount?
? the Platypus {aka David Formosa} wrote:
Ok first my understanding of the way drag (air resistence) works. There is two main sources of drag, the first one is from pushing the air away infrount of you, and the second source of drag is from the air rushing in to fill the partial vacume behind you. It's more the turbulance you leave behind you that slows you down. This is why stuff designed for areodynamics normally has the classic teardrop shape, with the tail out the end to allow the air to rush back in smoothly. The ideal shape isn't quite a teardrop. Aero modelling of the ideal shape has been done before, and it tends to appear a more bloated at the rear, rather than the sharp classic teardrop shape you're talking about. But this is besides the point anyway. Wouldn't having a bike behind you transfur the second sort of drag to him freeing you from this? If you're talking about normal bodies on normal bicycles, the aerodynamic shape of your typical human is complex, and the turbulance you leave behind you is by far worse than any effect the rider behind you is going to have. And this turns out to be a moot point anyway, because the frontal area exposed to the air has by far more of an effect than the turbulance drag anyway. This is why bicycles (most notably recuments) with even only small front nosecoses, have such a marked effect on overall average speed. With normal bikes however, in theory, if you could get close enough, it might have an effect, but due to the physical construction of bikes in general, you can't get close enough to make a difference. Best you can hope for is the person in front helps you, not you help them. -- Linux Registered User # 302622 http://counter.li.org |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Does drafting help the guy in frount?
On 12 Apr 2004 09:54:28 +1000, ? the Platypus {aka David Formosa}
may have said: Wouldn't having a bike behind you transfur the second sort of drag to him freeing you from this? No. The speed at which this would be beneficial to the drafted rider is not one that will be achieved on a human-powered bike. -- My email address is antispammed; pull WEEDS if replying via e-mail. Typoes are not a bug, they're a feature. Words processed in a facility that contains nuts. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Does drafting help the guy in frount?
In ,
? the Platypus {aka David Formosa} typed: Ok first my understanding of the way drag (air resistence) works. There is two main sources of drag, the first one is from pushing the air away infrount of you, and the second source of drag is from the air rushing in to fill the partial vacume behind you. This is why stuff designed for areodynamics normally has the classic teardrop shape, with the tail out the end to allow the air to rush back in smoothly. Wouldn't having a bike behind you transfur the second sort of drag to him freeing you from this? According to this yes. http://www.exploratorium.com/cycling/aerodynamics2.html Mike |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Does drafting help the guy in frount?
? the Platypus {aka David Formosa} wrote:
Ok first my understanding of the way drag (air resistence) works. There is two main sources of drag, the first one is from pushing the air away infrount of you, and the second source of drag is from the air rushing in to fill the partial vacume behind you. This is why stuff designed for areodynamics normally has the classic teardrop shape, with the tail out the end to allow the air to rush back in smoothly. Wouldn't having a bike behind you transfur the second sort of drag to him freeing you from this? This can provide a significant advantage to first rider if they are both in streamliners - quite important to the 30 or 40 people worldwide who race these. A bigger advantage can be provided by having a closely trailing large vehicle such a motor home (caravan), bus or truck (lorry) that produces a significant bow wave. -- Tom Sherman - Quad Cities (Illinois Side) |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Does drafting help the guy in frount?
On Sun, 11 Apr 2004 20:09:49 -0500, Tom Sherman
may have said: This can provide a significant advantage to first rider if they are both in streamliners - quite important to the 30 or 40 people worldwide who race these. A bigger advantage can be provided by having a closely trailing large vehicle such a motor home (caravan), bus or truck (lorry) that produces a significant bow wave. However, the increase in power delivered to the pedals due to the sheer terror induced by the close proximity of several tons of screaming death metal probably will have a greater effect on the rider's output than the bow wave will have on his speed. -- My email address is antispammed; pull WEEDS if replying via e-mail. Typoes are not a bug, they're a feature. Words processed in a facility that contains nuts. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Does drafting help the guy in frount?
Werehatrack wrote:
... A bigger advantage can be provided by having a closely trailing large vehicle such a motor home (caravan), bus or truck (lorry) that produces a significant bow wave. However, the increase in power delivered to the pedals due to the sheer terror induced by the close proximity of several tons of screaming death metal probably will have a greater effect on the rider's output than the bow wave will have on his speed. IIRC, this has been an issue in some cycling competitions where the bow wave effect has been used to gain an advantage. -- Tom Sherman - Quad Cities (Illinois Side |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Does drafting help the guy in frount?
Werehatrack wrote:
On Sun, 11 Apr 2004 20:09:49 -0500, Tom Sherman may have said: A bigger advantage can be provided by having a closely trailing large vehicle such a motor home (caravan), bus or truck (lorry) that produces a significant bow wave. However, the increase in power delivered to the pedals due to the sheer terror induced by the close proximity of several tons of screaming death metal probably will have a greater effect on the rider's output than the bow wave will have on his speed. I found and subsequently confirmed that the best way to heighten the adrenalin effect is to have one's front wheel come into contact with the drafted vehicle under hard braking resulting in significant rear wheel lift. -- R. Richard Brockie "Categorical statements The tall blond one. always cause trouble." |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Does drafting help the guy in frount?
"? the Platypus {aka David Formosa}" wrote in message ... Ok first my understanding of the way drag (air resistence) works. There is two main sources of drag, the first one is from pushing the air away infrount of you, and the second source of drag is from the air rushing in to fill the partial vacume behind you. This is why stuff designed for areodynamics normally has the classic teardrop shape, with the tail out the end to allow the air to rush back in smoothly. SNIP As a follow up question, has any reputable research been done to analyze the effects of having a rider in your draft at different speeds. I always find it interesting to listen to announcers of road bike races say things like: When a rider breaks from the pack on a major climb and someone jumps on his wheel: "That will slow him down, having a rider in your draft on a climb has the effect of you towing him uphill. It is much harder for the lead rider than going alone." When the whole peleton is together and flying on the flats: "The effects of riding in a group can save as much as 50% effort." I know that bicycle racing has a long history of traditions without any supporting facts, but I don't a lot concerning the truth in this area. Bob. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Does drafting help the guy in frount?
There are different types of drag. The main one affecting cyclists is
form drag, produced by the flow of air around you. You push at the air in front, increasing pressure, and its flow is turbulent because of your shape. This causes a decrease of pressure behind you which tends to suck you backwards (triathletes will know about this). Swimming has changed heaps over the years as this has become better understood - a longer, streamlined shape causes less turbulence in the flow so there is not such a low pressure area behind. The second cyclist takes it easy because the low pressure behind the cyclist in front sucks him/her forward - and the pressure behind the 2nd cyclist will be higher than it was behind the first cyclist (because of less turbulence from a longer, more streamlined body). Most people understand this bit. The way that the rear cyclist would help the front cyclist most is if they increased the pressure in between them. Given that there is reduced turbulent flow behind the first cyclist, the pressure might not drop so low. However a lot of this cyclist's energy is going to the second cyclist - as they are pushing the air out of the way for both. Or, to think of it in laymans terms, if there was 2 litres of air in front that one cyclist had to displace (push out of the way) leaving a 2 litre hole behind him, and lots of energy is wasted in creating this hole and the air flows turbulently back in behind him/her. But when there's 2 cyclists there's less turbulence (seen) which effectively means there's a smaller hole behind them - maybe only 1 litre - but the first cyclist still displaced 2 litres, which means there had to be a smaller hole behind him too, thanks to the other cyclist. I think a fish-shaped pack would work better, widening quickly from the first cyclist and then tapering slowly. T |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Rules of drafting | Wayne Harrison | Australia | 12 | March 10th 04 11:30 PM |
Drafting etiquette | [email protected] | Australia | 16 | February 13th 04 07:28 AM |